Sentiment Washout: Capitulation or Just Oversold?
After a 9% three-week decline, VIX is 31 and VIX3M is 26, an inverted term structure. The CBOE equity put/call five-day average is 1.28, AAII bears are 51% versus bulls at 22%, and NAAIM exposure is 34. The S&P 500 sits 4% above its rising 200-day MA and has held that average for three sessions. Breadth is weak: only 38% of S&P 500 members are above their 50-day MA. High-yield spreads have widened 70 bp but remain below their one-year average. Volume has been above average on down days, and the put/call has stayed elevated for six sessions rather than spiking once. The 10-day TRIN closed at 1.9 yesterday and 1.4 today. Your benchmark is 60/40 and you are currently 5% underweight equities; the mandate allows adding 3% equity beta.
1. Separate sentiment from positioning and identify what is missing for a capitulation call.
Read the worked answer
These are mostly sentiment and positioning measures, not timing signals. VIX at 31 with an inverted VIX/VIX3M term structure indicates acute near-term stress and strong demand for protection. AAII bears at 51% and NAAIM at 34 show retail and active managers have de-risked. A five-day put/call average of 1.28 is elevated but not extreme relative to panic readings above 1.5. What is missing is price confirmation: breadth at 38% above the 50-day MA is weak but not a washout, and TRIN at 1.9 then 1.4 shows selling pressure easing, not climaxing. High-yield spreads widened 70 bp but remain below average, so credit is not confirming systemic stress. Sentiment says washout conditions exist; it does not say the low is in.
2. What would confirm a tradeable low rather than a pause? Be specific about volatility, breadth, price, and credit.
Read the worked answer
A tradeable low typically requires several independent confirmations. First, a volatility spike and reversal: VIX closing below the prior day's low, or the VIX/VIX3M term structure un-inverting. Second, a breadth thrust: the percent above the 50-day MA recovering from below 40 to above 55 within ten sessions, or a 10-day up/down volume ratio above 1.5. Third, a price failure to make new lows on bad news, or a reversal day on above-average volume. Fourth, credit spreads stabilizing for at least five sessions. Without those, sentiment extremes can persist for weeks and the market can pause before falling further. Holding the rising 200-day MA is constructive but not sufficient by itself.
3. How would you scale into the 3% addition and define invalidation?
Read the worked answer
Scale in thirds. Add 1% now only if you can tolerate another 5-7% drawdown; add the second third on a breadth thrust or on VIX3M moving back above VIX; add the final third on a close above the prior swing high. Define invalidation as a weekly close below the 200-day MA accompanied by high-yield spreads making new highs, which would shift the thesis from sentiment washout to credit event. Use options to define risk-buy three-month puts or put spreads rather than stopping out of cash equity. Keep the total addition to 3% beta and pre-commit to the levels. Do not average down if credit deteriorates, because the sentiment case depends on credit remaining stable.