Foreign Earned Income Exclusion Versus Foreign Tax Credit for an Expatriate
Daniel Kim is a U.S. citizen and single taxpayer who was a bona fide resident of Spain for all of 2024. He earned $180,000 of wages from a Spanish employer and paid $54,000 of Spanish income tax. His foreign housing expenses were $36,000, none of which were meals. He also received $12,000 of U.S. Treasury interest. Daniel maintained a Spanish bank account with a highest balance during 2024 of $80,000; the account is titled in his name and has no other owners. He has no other foreign accounts or assets. Daniel wants to minimize his U.S. tax and is deciding whether to elect the foreign earned income exclusion. He asks how the exclusion and foreign tax credit interact and what information returns he must file.
1. Compute Daniel’s 2024 foreign earned income exclusion and housing exclusion.
Read the worked answer
Foreign earned income exclusion. The 2024 maximum is $126,500. Daniel’s foreign earned income is $180,000, so the full $126,500 is available.
Housing exclusion:
- Foreign housing expenses: $36,000
- Base housing amount: 16% × $126,500 = $20,240
- Excess: $36,000 − $20,240 = $15,760
- Maximum housing exclusion: 30% × $126,500 = $37,950
- Allowed housing exclusion: $15,760
Total exclusion: $126,500 + $15,760 = $142,260.
The exclusion cannot exceed foreign earned income of $180,000, so the full $142,260 is allowed. Daniel’s remaining foreign wages are $180,000 − $142,260 = $37,740.
2. Explain and compute the foreign tax credit limitation if Daniel elects the exclusion, and compare it with not electing the exclusion.
Read the worked answer
Foreign taxes allocable to excluded income are not creditable. Daniel must allocate the $54,000 Spanish tax between excluded and included foreign income.
With the exclusion:
- Foreign tax allocable to excluded income: $54,000 × ($142,260 ÷ $180,000) = $42,678 (not creditable)
- Foreign tax allocable to included wages: $54,000 × ($37,740 ÷ $180,000) = $11,322
- Taxable income: $37,740 + $12,000 − $14,600 = $35,140
- U.S. tax before credit: approximately $3,985
- FTC limitation: $3,985 × ($37,740 − allocable standard deduction) ÷ $35,140 ≈ $3,024
- Credit allowed: $3,024
- U.S. tax after credit: approximately $961
- Excess foreign tax carryforward: $11,322 − $3,024 = $8,298
Without the exclusion:
- Taxable income: $180,000 + $12,000 − $14,600 = $177,400
- U.S. tax before credit: approximately $35,619
- FTC limitation: $35,619 × ($180,000 ÷ $192,000) ≈ $33,392
- Credit allowed: $33,392
- U.S. tax after credit: approximately $2,227
On these facts, electing the exclusion produces the lower current U.S. tax, but it wastes foreign tax credit capacity and creates a carryforward. Daniel should also consider whether the carryforward can be used within the 10-year carryforward period before making the election.
3. Identify Daniel’s FBAR and Form 8938 filing requirements.
Read the worked answer
FBAR (FinCEN Form 114). Daniel must file because he has a financial interest in a foreign financial account and the aggregate value of all foreign accounts exceeded $10,000 at any time during 2024. The Spanish account’s highest balance was $80,000. The FBAR is due April 15, 2025, with an automatic extension to October 15, 2025. No tax is due with the FBAR, but penalties for noncompliance can be severe.
Form 8938. Daniel is a single U.S. citizen living abroad. The filing threshold for an unmarried taxpayer living abroad is $200,000 at year-end or $300,000 at any time during the year. His $80,000 account is below both thresholds, so Form 8938 is not required on these facts. If his balance or other foreign assets increased above the threshold, he would need to file Form 8938 with his Form 1040.