The Plume, the Video and the Plane
At 14:05 a vapour release occurs in a flavourings plant's solvent handling area. Three contractors are taken to hospital, one with breathing difficulty. By 14:25 a smartphone video of a visible plume is circulating in a local Facebook group, and a reporter is at the gate. The chemical's identity is not yet confirmed - the line handles two solvents, one of which is far more hazardous than the other. The regulator has not been notified. The pre-approved holding statement in the crisis comms pack names the more hazardous substance. The corporate communications director is airborne and unreachable for three hours. The site manager wants to wait for confirmation before saying anything.
1. What is your first external communication, when does it go out, and who speaks?
Read the worked answer
Issue a holding statement within the hour - silence with a plume on video is itself a message, and it reads as concealment.
But edit the template. The pre-approved statement names a substance the incident team has not confirmed. Naming the wrong chemical is a durable, quoted, un-retractable error; the template exists for speed, not for accuracy. Strip it to what is known: an incident occurred, emergency services attended, three people are receiving medical attention, next update at a stated time.
Avoid 'there is no risk to the public' unless that has been technically confirmed. Prefer what you can stand behind: 'we are working with the emergency services and will confirm details as they are verified.'
Who speaks: one voice, named, with authority to speak for the site. The comms director's absence must not paralyse this - delegated authority should have been pre-agreed, and the incident commander or a trained site spokesperson should hold the line. If your plan only works when one person is on the ground, the plan is not resilient.
2. Employees' families are calling the switchboard. How would you sequence internal and external communication?
Read the worked answer
Internal first, every time, and by voice rather than email. Employees are the most affected, the most credible amplifiers, and the most likely to contradict you publicly if they feel uninformed.
Sequence: (1) a hotline or broadcast to all staff within the first hour - what happened, what to do if a family member calls, where to get updates; (2) direct, personal contact with the families of the three injured contractors before any public statement that refers to casualties, because they should never learn the scale from a news bulletin; (3) external statement; (4) local residents and neighbours, particularly if the plume has left the site boundary.
Expect the sequence to compress. If external media is live before your internal cascade is complete, do not withhold the external statement - instead pre-brief the families and shop-floor supervisors first, so that the person answering the phone is not hearing it from the reporter.
3. The regulator has not been notified at 70 minutes. What is the right call, and what tension are you managing?
Read the worked answer
Notify now, with what you know, marked 'initial notification'. Statutory notification deadlines are legal obligations, generally running from awareness rather than from full understanding - waiting for confirmation risks converting an incident into a compliance failure on top of an incident.
Name the tension explicitly: legal caution pulls toward saying nothing until the facts are settled; reputational and regulatory reality pulls toward early, calibrated disclosure. The resolution is not to choose one - it is to give the regulator the status of your knowledge, not a polished narrative. 'Confirmed: release in solvent handling area. Unconfirmed: identity of substance. Action: evacuation, three hospitalised, investigation underway. Next update: 16:30.'
Also record who decided what and when. A logged, timestamped decision trail is what distinguishes a defensible judgement under uncertainty from an unexplained delay when the regulator later reviews it.