The Basement That Wasn't Disclosed
You list a 1978 split-level at $485,000 for a seller who has owned it 19 years. During the listing appointment she mentions that after heavy rain the basement carpet gets damp and she has a $9,500 quote for interior drain tile. She says, 'Leave it off the disclosure-it's handled with a dehumidifier, and buyers overreact.' You also learn the furnace was replaced in 2022 without a permit. At the open house a buyer's agent asks whether the basement has ever leaked. Separately, your seller says to tell every caller 'no repair credits, sold as-is,' although she told you privately she would give up to $6,000 rather than lose the deal.
1. The seller instructs you to omit the basement seepage and the unpermitted furnace from the disclosure. What do you do, and why?
Read the worked answer
You cannot comply. In most U.S. states, a seller's disclosure statute requires disclosure of known material defects, and license law and the REALTOR Code prohibit misrepresentation and require protecting the public. A verbal 'it's handled' does not cure a known water-intrusion history or unpermitted work.
Practical steps:
- Tell the seller plainly that you will not list or continue the listing with an inaccurate disclosure. Explain the exposure: rescission, repair claims, E&O, license discipline, and fraud allegations.
- Have the seller complete a corrected disclosure identifying prior moisture, the drain-tile quote, and the unpermitted furnace replacement.
- Recommend the seller consult an attorney and the local building department about permitting the furnace; do not give legal advice yourself.
- Document the conversation in the file and confirm the corrected disclosure in writing.
An 'as-is' sale does not permit concealing known latent defects. If the seller insists on nondisclosure, terminate the listing according to your brokerage policy and state law.
2. At the open house, the buyer's agent asks you directly, 'Has the basement ever leaked?' How should you answer?
Read the worked answer
Answer truthfully and without speculation. Confidentiality does not authorize a false statement. A workable response is: 'The seller has reported moisture in the basement after heavy rain and has obtained a drain-tile quote; the written disclosure will identify that history. I don't have information beyond what the seller has provided.'
Reasoning:
- You are not required to volunteer every detail at an open house, but you may not deny a known defect or imply the basement is dry.
- Do not offer a contractor's opinion or diagnose the cause. Stick to what the seller disclosed and direct the buyer to the written disclosure and their own inspection.
- If the written disclosure is not yet available, say so and follow up promptly rather than improvising an answer.
- Document the question and your response, because a later dispute may focus on what was said at the showing.
3. The seller wants you to tell buyers 'no repair credits' while privately authorizing up to $6,000. How do you handle the negotiation instruction?
Read the worked answer
You may keep the seller's authorization confidential, but you may not state a false position. 'The seller will not consider any credit' is a factual claim you know to be untrue.
Use accurate framing instead:
- 'The home is priced to reflect its condition, and the seller is not inviting repair requests; all offers will be presented.'
- If asked whether the seller will credit, say: 'The seller will evaluate offers as presented.' That preserves flexibility without revealing the ceiling.
- Explain to the seller that a false hardline often backfires: buyers walk, agents stop bringing offers, and the listing gains a reputation for being unreasonable.
- Confirm in writing the range the seller has authorized and note that you will not misstate it.
If the seller insists that you affirmatively tell buyers 'zero credits, ever,' refuse and escalate to your broker. You can decline to reveal a negotiating range; you cannot lie about it.