Nine Days to Deadline, One Clicking Laptop
The examination officer at a small secondary school keeps all internal and CSEC coursework records - about 1,900 files going back nine years - in a folder called EXAMS on an eight-year-old laptop. Her backup routine is to copy the folder to a USB drive that lives in the same laptop bag, and to email the most important spreadsheets to her personal Gmail account. Last week the laptop began freezing and making a clicking noise, and three Word files now open with a 'file is corrupt' message. The USB drive, when she tries it, displays 'you need to format this disk'. The Gmail account is at 14.7 GB of its 15 GB limit, and the last backup email she can find is 14 months old. The examination board's portal closes for marks submission in nine days, and paper mark sheets exist for the current Form 5 cohort only.
1. What should she do in the next 48 hours, in order, and why does the order matter?
Read the worked answer
Stop, then copy. The clicking suggests a failing mechanical drive; every boot, repair or disk check writes to it and can finish it off. Power it down and have an image or clone made before any further use - a technician with a write-blocker or a Linux live USB, or a professional if the older records are irreplaceable.
Do not format the USB. 'You need to format this disk' is a symptom, not an instruction; try it on another machine and, if that fails, use recovery software that reads without writing.
Recover the three corrupt Word files from AutoRecover or temporary files, and try opening them in LibreOffice or uploading them to Google Docs, which can sometimes repair them.
Work in deadline order: Form 5 marks first, rebuilt from the paper sheets, and a written extension request to the board on day one - a request sent on day eight will be refused. Older records can wait a week; the portal will not.
2. Design a backup plan using the 3-2-1 rule and tools the school already has, with a schedule and a test.
Read the worked answer
3-2-1 means three copies, on two kinds of media, with one offsite. Practical version: (1) the working copy on the laptop; (2) an automatic copy to the school's Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 account, which keeps version history and is offsite by default; (3) a monthly copy to an external hard drive kept in the principal's office or another building - not in the laptop bag.
Schedule: automatic sync daily; external drive on the first Friday of each month, with a written log and initials. Once a term, restore a random file from each copy and open it - a backup that has never been restored is a hope, not a backup. Train a second staff member, because the current setup has one point of failure: one person, one bag, one drawer. Also move the records off a personal Gmail account to a school-managed account, since a personal mailbox leaves with the person who owns it and has no version history or retention rule.
3. Explain why 'it is saved in my email and in the cloud' did not protect her.
Read the worked answer
Email was never a backup. The 15 GB limit was reached silently, so the routine stopped 14 months ago and nothing warned her. Gmail is also a mailbox, not an archive: attachments are hard to find, easy to delete by accident, and tied to a personal account the school neither controls nor backs up. If she left, the account could be closed and the copies with it.
The USB failed because it lived in the same bag as the laptop: a theft, a spill, or a bag left on a bus takes both copies at once, and a USB stick keeps no version history, so a corrupted copy replaces a good one.
And 'in the cloud' only helps if the copy is separate from the original. Had the EXAMS folder been syncing to Drive, a deletion or an encryption by ransomware would have propagated to the cloud within seconds. Sync is not backup; version history and a separate, versioned copy are.