BuildRight Hardware: The Big Box Arrives
BuildRight Hardware is an independent store in Georgetown, Guyana, with 22 employees and annual sales of GY$48 million. A regional chain is opening a larger store 2 km away, advertising lower prices and extended hours. In the last quarter BuildRight's sales fell 12%, and stock turnover dropped from 6 to 4.5 times a year. The government has raised import duty on some fittings from 20% to 35%, and the minimum wage rose by 8%. Two suppliers now demand cash on delivery. Customers are posting negative comments on social media about long queues and missing items. The owner is considering cutting four staff, reducing the product range to fast-moving items, and starting a delivery service for contractors. Employees are worried about job losses, and the local community has supported the store for 20 years.
1. Using external environment categories, identify two external factors and explain their impact on BuildRight.
Read the worked answer
Economic factors: the new chain increases competition and has already contributed to a 12% sales fall and slower stock turnover from 6 to 4.5. Higher import duty from 20% to 35% raises the cost of some fittings, squeezing margin or raising prices. The 8% minimum wage increase raises wage costs. Social factor: negative social media comments about queues and missing items can damage reputation and drive customers to the chain. Legal and political factors: duty and wage rules are external and cannot be controlled. The cash-on-delivery demand from two suppliers is a supplier pressure that tightens working capital. Together these explain why BuildRight cannot simply match the chain's prices; it must protect cash and differentiate on service.
2. Recommend a response plan for BuildRight. Justify why you would or would not cut four staff.
Read the worked answer
Recommended response: (1) do not cut four staff immediately; instead freeze non-essential hiring and reduce overtime, because queues and missing items are already service problems. (2) Use ABC stock analysis to keep fast-moving and contractor-critical items, and special-order slow movers. (3) Negotiate with suppliers for partial credit or smaller frequent deliveries; if refused, prioritise cash for core lines. (4) Launch contractor delivery with a minimum order and a delivery fee to protect margin. (5) Fix social media complaints with a simple response and stock-check routine. Cutting staff may lower costs but worsen the service symptoms that are losing sales; redeploy one counter person to stock control and delivery coordination.
3. Evaluate the proposal to reduce the product range to fast-moving items only.
Read the worked answer
Reducing the range to fast-moving items improves stock turnover and releases cash, which is urgent given the 4.5 turnover and cash-on-delivery terms. But BuildRight serves contractors who value one-stop shopping; dropping slow-moving but essential fittings could push them to the chain. A better judgement is to classify stock: A items always in stock, B items stocked in smaller quantities, C items special order with a deposit. Keep a small core of contractor essentials even if slow, and drop only duplicated or obsolete lines. Review after eight weeks using sales per square metre, stock turnover, and lost-sale records. This balances cash recovery with customer retention.