No Turn on Red With a Cyclist and Pedestrian Present
At 8:15 a.m. on a Tuesday, you are driving south on a two-lane DC street and approach a red traffic signal at a T-intersection. You want to turn right onto a one-way street. A sign beside the signal reads 'NO TURN ON RED 7–9 AM AND 4–6 PM MON–FRI.' The pavement has a crosswalk and a dashed bike lane on your right. A pedestrian is standing at the curb but has not stepped off; a cyclist is approaching in the bike lane from behind you. Traffic on the one-way street is moving slowly. Your view of the crosswalk is partly blocked by a parked delivery van on the left, but the signal and sign are clear. You have been waiting for 30 seconds, and the driver behind you taps the horn. You must decide whether to turn, whom to yield to, and what to do if the light turns green while the pedestrian is still waiting.
1. May you make the right turn while the signal is red? Explain the legal and safety reasoning.
Read the worked answer
No. The sign is a regulatory restriction, not a suggestion. It prohibits right turns on red from 7 to 9 a.m. Monday through Friday, and this is Tuesday at 8:15 a.m. The general DC rule that allows a right turn on red after a full stop and yield does not override a posted prohibition. The horn from behind does not create permission. You should stop behind the stop line and crosswalk, not creep into it, because the delivery van limits your view and a pedestrian is at the curb. Turning now would be a signal violation and could put you into conflict with the cyclist in the bike lane. Wait for the green signal, then turn only after yielding to pedestrians and cyclists.
2. What must you check and yield to before turning if the signal turns green while the pedestrian is still waiting?
Read the worked answer
A green light gives you permission to proceed, not an absolute right of way. Before turning right, signal, check the mirror and blind spot for the cyclist, and look left-right-left for pedestrians. The pedestrian at the curb has not entered the crosswalk yet, so you may proceed only if you can do so safely without crowding or startling them; if they step into the crosswalk, stop and let them cross. The cyclist in the bike lane has a through path, so do not turn across it unless you have yielded and there is a clear gap. Keep the crosswalk clear and do not cut the corner.
3. The driver behind honks again and edges forward. What is the safest response?
Read the worked answer
Stay stopped and do not move into the crosswalk or turn just to satisfy the driver behind. The horn does not change the sign or the right-of-way rules. Creeping forward reduces your escape space and may block the pedestrian or bike lane. Keep your foot on the brake, leave a little room ahead, and wait for the legal green phase. When the light changes, make the turn deliberately after the required checks. If the rear driver becomes threatening, avoid confrontation; once you have legally cleared the intersection, pull over safely if needed and contact authorities if there is an immediate danger.