The Unlicensed Nephew on a Six-Person Team
Devon leads a six-person team affiliated with a DC brokerage. His licensed assistant quit, so he brings in his nephew Ray, who finished the DC licensing course but has not sat for the exam and holds no license. Devon has Ray: (1) staff a Saturday open house at 4110 Kansas Ave NW and answer questions about price, square footage, and whether the seller will take less; (2) email a pre-written counteroffer to a buyer's agent from Devon's account; (3) post an Instagram reel captioned "Call Ray - DC's hardest-working negotiator"; and (4) hand-deliver a fully signed contract to the title company. Devon tells Ray all four are clerical because Ray is paid hourly and gets no commission. The broker of record has not been told Ray exists.
1. Classify each of Ray's four activities as permissible or impermissible for an unlicensed person, and explain the line you are drawing.
Read the worked answer
The dividing line is whether the person is performing a real estate brokerage service - negotiating, soliciting, advising on terms, or holding out as qualified to do so - versus ministerial support with no exercise of judgment and no client-facing persuasion.
(1) Open house with pricing and negotiating Q&A - impermissible. Answering "will the seller take less" is negotiation. Even giving price and square footage becomes brokerage when it is delivered to induce a consumer's decision. Ray may unlock the door and hand out pre-printed brochures only if a licensee is present, and he may not discuss terms, condition, or strategy.
(2) Emailing a pre-written counteroffer - gray, and here impermissible. Mere transmittal of a document authored and approved by a licensee can be ministerial, but a counteroffer is a negotiation instrument, and transmitting it under his own initiative from Devon's account with client-facing communication is brokerage. Safer: a licensee sends it.
(3) Instagram reel calling him a "negotiator" - impermissible. This is holding out as a person who provides brokerage services. It also fails advertising rules: the brokerage name must appear, and advertising must be under broker supervision.
(4) Hand-delivering a signed contract - generally permissible. No judgment, no advice, no solicitation. Even here, Ray should not discuss the document with anyone at the table.
2. What are the broker of record's supervisory duties, and does Devon's "no commission" explanation help him?
Read the worked answer
The compensation argument is irrelevant. Licensing law regulates who may perform brokerage services, not who gets paid for them. An unpaid volunteer who negotiates is still engaged in unlicensed brokerage; the hourly wage actually makes it look like the firm built an unlicensed sales function into its operation.
The broker of record's duties:
- Know who is on the team and in what capacity. A six-person team with an unannounced worker is a supervision failure independent of what Ray did.
- Supervise advertising - brokerage name, no misleading claims, prior review of social media.
- Ensure only licensees perform licensed activities and that unlicensed staff receive written guidelines on their permitted scope.
- Maintain and review transaction files, including who communicated with consumers.
Devon's exposure: as team leader he is an associate broker or salesperson exercising de facto supervision; the Commission can pursue him for aiding unlicensed activity, for advertising violations, and for failing to keep the principal broker informed. Team structures do not dilute the broker of record's responsibility - they multiply the points of failure the broker must control.
3. The broker of record learns of Ray on Monday and a consumer complaint about the open house arrives Friday. What should happen now?
Read the worked answer
Immediate corrective action, then full disclosure, then documentation - in that order.
Stop the conduct: pull Ray from all consumer-facing activity, delete or correct the Instagram reel, and notify the buyers' agents whose files Ray touched so they can confirm nothing in the negotiation was mishandled.
Assess the transactions: review every file Ray came near. If a counteroffer was transmitted and a party relied on the communication, the broker needs to confirm the terms actually communicated match what the licensees intended.
Disclose: the principal broker should report the situation through the firm's compliance channel and respond candidly to the complaint. Concealing the unlicensed worker after notice converts a correctable staffing error into an integrity problem.
Expect the range of consequences: the Commission may impose fines, require education, suspend or revoke licenses, and the firm may face civil exposure; unlicensed brokerage is also independently unlawful. The mitigation is promptness, cooperation, and a written unlicensed-assistant policy going forward.
Do not: backdate the file, tell Ray he was "just clerical" in writing, or let Devon handle the response alone.