The Handwritten Collateral Receipt
Luis is charged with felony DUI in Sussex County, and bail is set at $75,000 surety. His sister Rosa meets agent Dana. Dana quotes the rate filed by her surety: 10% premium ($7,500), plus a $150 paperwork fee, and requires a car title as collateral. Rosa pays $4,000 cash, signs an installment note for $3,650, and leaves the car title. Dana writes a receipt on office letterhead: 'Received $4,000 and car title for Luis bond.' She does not describe the car, VIN, or value, and does not give Rosa a copy. Dana deposits the $4,000 into her personal checking account and remits the $7,500 premium to the surety 45 days later, after the bond is posted. Luis appears at all hearings, and the bond is exonerated. Rosa asks for the title back. Dana says she will hold it for 60 days 'in case anything comes up' and that the $150 fee is nonrefundable. Rosa also asks whether the $3,650 note is still owed.
1. Evaluate the premium, the $150 fee, and the installment note under Delaware bail bond contracting principles.
Read the worked answer
The premium is 10% of $75,000, or $7,500, but Dana must confirm that this matches the rate filed by her surety and approved by the Department. A separate paperwork fee is permissible only if it is disclosed, agreed to, and consistent with the filed rate and insurer rules; an undisclosed or unfiled charge may have to be refunded. The premium is generally earned once the bond is posted, absent fraud or early exoneration under the contract. The $3,650 installment note is a credit agreement for the unpaid premium, not additional collateral. It is enforceable if the terms are clear, Rosa understood them, and the total charge does not exceed what the filed rate permits. Dana should not treat the note as a penalty or as a reason to keep collateral after the bond is exonerated.
2. What is wrong with Dana's collateral receipt and handling of funds, and what should a compliant receipt contain?
Read the worked answer
The receipt is inadequate because it does not identify the collateral, its value, the bond it secures, the conditions for return, or the parties' signatures. A compliant receipt should list the vehicle year, make, model, VIN, title number, lienholder if any, stated value, date received, the defendant and indemnitor names, the bond amount and court, and the circumstances under which the collateral will be returned or applied. Rosa should receive a copy. Dana also mishandled funds by depositing premium money into a personal account and delaying remittance for 45 days. Premium and collateral should be safeguarded under the insurer's trust or escrow procedures, not commingled with personal funds. Collateral should be stored securely and accounted for in the bond file.
3. What should Dana do now regarding the title, the note, and the $150 fee?
Read the worked answer
Because the bond has been exonerated and no forfeiture or unpaid premium obligation appears in the facts, Dana should promptly return the car title and provide an itemized written accounting. She should not impose an unsupported 60-day hold; any hold must be authorized by the signed contract or insurer rules. The $3,650 note remains owed only to the extent it represents unpaid earned premium and complies with the filed rate; Dana should reconcile payments and cancel or correct any excess. The $150 fee should be retained only if it was properly disclosed and permitted; otherwise she should refund it. Dana should also correct her trust-accounting practice, document the return of the title, and keep copies of all receipts and correspondence.