The Landlord Who Wants It Quiet
You complete a risk assessment for a rented single-family home. You find deteriorated paint on interior window components and elevated dust loadings on sills in the child's bedroom. The child has had two blood lead tests in the 5–9 µg/dL range. The landlord, who is your client, asks you to 'keep the dust numbers out of the report because they'll scare the tenant and it's not that bad.' He also asks you not to mention the child's blood lead results because 'that's medical.' The tenant has not seen your findings.
1. How do you handle the landlord's request to omit the dust results and the blood lead information?
Read the worked answer
You cannot omit the dust results. They are the objective basis for the hazard determination and for any recommendation to control or abate. A report that suppresses them is misleading and could delay protective action.
The blood lead results are the tenant's information; you should not broadcast them unnecessarily, but you can and should reference that a child occupant has documented elevated exposure as part of the hazard characterization, with appropriate privacy care. The correct approach is to report the environmental findings fully and to communicate the hazard to the occupants in a way that does not disclose unnecessary personal health details.
2. Who is entitled to your findings, and how do you balance client confidentiality against occupant safety?
Read the worked answer
Your contract is with the landlord, but the occupants are the people at risk. Professional ethics and the regulatory framework for lead hazard communication require that occupants be informed of identified lead hazards in their dwelling. You should:
- Tell the landlord you will report the findings accurately.
- Provide the required hazard information to the tenant.
- Keep the report factual and avoid unnecessary disclosure of medical details.
- Document the landlord's request and your response.
Confidentiality to the client does not extend to concealing a hazard from the people exposed to it.