Commingled Deposit, Seller Demand, and Threat of Forfeiture
Gina is the auctioneer and closing agent for a farm-equipment auction. Winning bidder Omar wires a $25,000 deposit to Gina's business operating account. The seller, Wes, demands the deposit immediately because he needs cash for a new tractor. Gina uses $10,000 of the deposit to pay her auction advertising invoice. Wes and Omar later dispute whether a loader was included in the sale. Gina tells Omar he forfeits the deposit unless he closes in 48 hours, though the contract says disputes go to mediation.
1. Analyze Gina's escrow and trust-accounting violations.
Read the worked answer
Gina's handling violates basic trust-accounting duties. Buyer deposits and funds held for others are trust funds, not operating capital. They must be deposited in a segregated escrow or trust account, not the auctioneer's business operating account, and they cannot be used to pay advertising or other business expenses. Commingling and conversion are serious violations even if Gina intends to repay. She should have a client ledger showing Omar's $25,000, receipts, and disbursements. The seller is not entitled to the deposit merely because he demands it; the deposit secures the buyer's performance and is disbursed per the contract after closing or forfeiture. Using $10,000 for advertising creates a shortfall and a conflict.
2. How should Gina handle the competing demands and the mediation clause?
Read the worked answer
Gina should not threaten forfeiture while the loader dispute is unresolved and the contract requires mediation. She should hold the deposit in trust, notify both parties in writing, and follow the contract's dispute clause. If they cannot agree, she may ask a court to allow interpleader or seek written instructions from both. She should not disburse to Wes without Omar's written authorization or a final settlement or order. She should document all communications and avoid acting as judge. The 48-hour ultimatum is inconsistent with the mediation clause and may be seen as coercion.
3. What records and controls should Gina implement?
Read the worked answer
She needs separate trust and operating accounts, a receipt for each deposit, a client ledger, monthly reconciliations, and written disbursement authorizations. Only funds due to the seller or auctioneer after closing should be transferred, and the transfer should be documented. She should have dual controls or a bookkeeper review, retain records for the required period, and never pay business expenses from trust. A written escrow policy and checklists for each auction would prevent repeat violations.