The Daughter Who Says We Ignore Her Mother
Mrs. L is 85 with moderate hearing loss and mild expressive aphasia after a stroke. She wears her hearing aids about half the time and needs long pauses to find words. Her daughter visits and tells the administrator that aides "ignore Mother - they just do things to her without asking." You are assigned to Mrs. L this morning. The television is on loud, her roommate is talking on the phone, and when you ask if she needs the toilet she turns her head away without answering. She has not been to the bathroom in four hours and had coffee with breakfast.
1. How do you get a reliable answer about whether she needs the toilet?
Read the worked answer
Reasoning: turning her head away is not a 'no' - it may be a hearing aid problem, a word-finding pause, or an attempt to hide incontinence. Treating it as refusal risks a fall or a wet bed.
- Fix the environment first: turn off or mute the TV, step to the side she can see, get at eye level, and check that her hearing aids are in, on, and have working batteries.
- Get her attention before speaking: touch her arm lightly, say her name, wait for eye contact.
- Speak low and clear, not loud. Shouting raises pitch and makes speech harder to understand for a hearing-impaired listener.
- Ask one closed question at a time and give a full 10–15 seconds of silence for her to find words: "Do you need to use the toilet now?" If she looks unsure, offer a gesture or a picture, and use yes/no by nodding.
- Confirm by action, not assumption: "Let's walk to the bathroom and try." Escort her; if she resists at the door, stop and document.
Four hours and coffee makes a try reasonable even without a clear verbal yes.
2. The daughter is upset and has already complained to the administrator. How do you respond to her, and what do you report and to whom?
Read the worked answer
Reasoning: she is reporting a real pattern - being 'done to' without explanation. Defending yourself loses the point; agreeing that staff are neglectful is also wrong.
Say to her: "Thank you for telling us. Your mother's hearing and her stroke make it easy for her to be left out of the conversation, and that's worth fixing." Then be specific about what you do: get her attention first, one question at a time, check the hearing aids, wait for her words, and tell her what you are about to do before you do it. Offer to show the daughter how to help.
Do not: argue, promise that "it will never happen again," discuss other residents, or blame the previous shift.
Report to the nurse and your supervisor the same day: the daughter's concern, that Mrs. L did not respond to a spoken question, that her hearing aids were not consistently in, and what you changed. That is a care-plan and communication issue, not a personality conflict.
3. What would you change about the room and your approach for the rest of the shift?
Read the worked answer
Reasoning: communication failure here is mostly environmental and pacing, both of which you control.
- Reduce competing noise: TV off during care, close the door, or move to a quieter spot for conversations.
- Face her, light on your face, mouth visible - no calling from the doorway or speaking while turned away.
- One idea per sentence, with a pause after each. Don't finish her sentences; guessing wrong frustrates her and teaches her to stop trying.
- Pair words with gestures and objects: hold the towel, point to the bathroom, demonstrate.
- Hearing aids in before conversation, not after; report to the nurse if they are broken, missing, or she refuses them, since that is a functional issue.
- Ask before doing, every time, even small care: "I'm going to wash your back now, all right?" That single habit answers the daughter's complaint directly.
- Watch for fatigue: aphasia worsens when she is tired. Do the talking parts of care early, not at the end of a long morning.