The Notary Who Owns Part of the Deal
Marisol is a Georgia notary public commissioned in Chatham County. She is also a 25% member and the office manager of Tidewater Renovations, LLC. The LLC is closing a $150,000 equipment loan. The bank's closing package includes (1) an operating agreement signed by all members, including Marisol; (2) a personal guaranty signed by the managing member, who is Marisol's cousin; and (3) a bank-required affidavit of no liens. The closing attorney, pressed for time, asks Marisol to notarize the managing member's signature on the guaranty and the affidavit, saying "you're already on the documents anyway." Marisol's commission is active, her seal is correct, and the managing member appears in person with a Georgia driver's license. Marisol wonders whether her ownership interest matters, whether the cousin relationship matters, and whether she can notarize only the affidavit because it is "just a bank form."
1. May Marisol notarize the managing member's signature on the personal guaranty and the affidavit of no liens? Analyze each document.
Read the worked answer
Marisol should decline both notarizations. Georgia notary law prohibits a notary from performing a notarial act on a document to which the notary is a party or in which the notary has a direct financial or beneficial interest. The personal guaranty secures a $150,000 loan to Tidewater Renovations. Because Marisol owns 25% of the LLC, the loan and the guaranty directly affect her ownership interest and financial exposure. Her interest is not remote or theoretical. The affidavit of no liens is part of the same loan transaction and is intended to induce the bank to lend money to her company. Calling it "just a bank form" does not change its legal effect. The cousin relationship is not the decisive issue by itself, but it adds an independence concern. A disinterested notary must handle both documents. If Marisol proceeds, the notarial certificates are improper, the bank or a court may reject or challenge them, and her commission may be at risk.
2. Could Marisol notarize the operating agreement if she signs it only as a member and not as notary?
Read the worked answer
No. The disqualification turns on Marisol's role in the transaction, not on which signature line she uses. If she signs the operating agreement as a member, she is a party to that instrument. She also has a direct ownership interest in the LLC that the operating agreement governs. She therefore cannot notarize any signature on that agreement, including her own or another member's. She may sign it as a member, and a different notary may notarize the signatures. The independent notary should verify each signer's identity, confirm that each signer appears in person, and complete a proper certificate. Marisol should not use her seal on that document at all.
3. What should the closing attorney do to keep the closing on schedule without creating a defective notarization?
Read the worked answer
The attorney should arrange for an independent Georgia notary who has no interest in the LLC or the loan. Marisol may sign the operating agreement as a member and may participate in the closing in her business capacity, but she must not act as notary on the loan package. The independent notary should handle the guaranty and the affidavit separately: confirm personal appearance, check a current government-issued photo ID, administer the oath for the affidavit, complete the venue, date, signer name, and notarial wording, then sign and seal. If the closing is happening remotely or after hours, the attorney should not ask Marisol to "cover" the notarization informally. A short delay is preferable to a defective certificate that the bank or a court may later reject.