Grinder, Extension Lead and a Wet Floor
At a food-processing plant, a three-person team is installing 20 mm PVC conduit along a wash-down wall. The apprentice cuts 41 × 41 mm unistrut with a 230 V, 230 mm angle grinder. The grinder is plugged into a fully coiled 25 m extension reel rated 13 A; the reel is fed from a socket with a portable 30 mA RCD whose test button has not been operated for three months. Wash-down water covers part of the floor. The grinder’s guard has been removed to reach a corner. A second electrician is drilling at 2.2 m on an aluminium step ladder while 400 V busbar trunking runs uncovered 2.8 m above the floor. Production is running, the area is not barriered, and the supervisor is off-site. The apprentice has not used a grinder before and is wearing safety boots but no face shield or hearing protection. A 10-minute job has become a two-hour task.
1. List the unsafe conditions in this scene and rank the three most serious. Justify each ranking using the likelihood and severity of harm, not just the rule that is broken.
Read the worked answer
Most serious hazards:
- Unguarded 230 mm grinder on a wet floor with an untrained user. Likelihood of contact with the wheel or ejected fragments is high, and the energy is enough for fatal or permanently disabling injury. The missing guard removes the primary engineering control.
- Live 400 V busbar trunking above an aluminium ladder. Aluminium conducts, the busbar is uncovered and the work area is not barriered. A slip or dropped tool could bridge to earth; severity is electrocution or a fall from height.
- Fully coiled 25 m extension reel at 13 A. The reel cannot dissipate heat, so the cable can overheat and ignite. This is serious but has a lower immediate injury likelihood than the first two. Also significant: no face or hearing protection, no RCD test for three months, no supervision, and production traffic. PPE is the last line of defence, so it does not outrank removing the guard or isolating the busbar.
2. State the immediate actions you would take as the senior person present, including who can authorise restart. Explain why lock-off and a permit are needed before the busbar area is re-entered.
Read the worked answer
Immediate actions:
- Stop the job and make the area safe. Isolate the grinder at the socket, remove the plug, and lock off the socket outlet. Do not just switch off at the tool.
- Barricade the busbar zone at floor level and post a warning. Keep the aluminium ladder out of the zone. If work overhead is essential, the busbar must be isolated and proved dead, or an engineered barrier installed.
- Replace the grinder guard before any further use; if the guard cannot be fitted, remove the tool from site. Uncoil the extension reel fully or use a reel rated for the load.
- Test the portable RCD and record the result. If it fails, quarantine it.
- Notify the plant engineer and the off-site supervisor. The supervisor cannot authorise restart by phone alone; the plant engineer or authorised person must approve a written permit-to-work for the busbar area. Restart requires a new risk assessment, verified isolation, guard fitted, RCD tested, and a competent, briefed operator. The apprentice must not use the grinder unsupervised until trained and assessed.
3. Draft the key points for a toolbox talk and a 10-minute permit briefing, and explain how you would verify the controls are working.
Read the worked answer
Toolbox talk and permit points:
- The task-specific hazards: wet floor, coiled reel, unguarded wheel, overhead live busbar, ladder work, and production traffic.
- The controls in order: eliminate the overhead work or isolate the busbar; substitute a guarded low-voltage tool or a reciprocating saw; engineer barriers and RCD protection; administrate a permit and exclusion zone; PPE as the last resort (face shield, hearing protection, gloves, boots).
- Stop-work authority: anyone can stop the job if a control fails.
- Emergency arrangements: first aid, isolation point, alarm, and rescue from height. Verification: check the RCD with its test button and a tester, inspect the guard and lead, confirm the permit is signed and the isolation lock is in place, and observe the apprentice for the first cut. Record the toolbox talk attendance and the permit in the site file. Re-check controls at the end of the shift.