Port State Detention, Rest Hours and a Charterer's Off-Hire Claim
Your 2012-built bulk carrier is detained in Rijeka after a PSC inspection. The inspection found: (1) 14 daily pages of the Oil Record Book missing for bilge water transfers; (2) four crew members' rest records show only 5 hours rest in the last 24 and 48 hours in the last 7 days; (3) the emergency fire pump delivers 0.25 MPa at 2 m³/h instead of the required pressure. The detention is expected to last 3 days. The charterers, who have 28,000 t of coal waiting, declare the vessel off-hire and claim damages for the delay. The flag State has been notified. The chief engineer says the ORB entries were 'forgotten'. The crew say the rest records are accurate. The master asks you, as superintendent, what to do.
1. Analyse the regulatory and legal exposure and the immediate corrective actions for the three deficiencies.
Read the worked answer
Oil Record Book. Missing pages for bilge water transfers are a detainable deficiency under MARPOL Annex I. If the transfers were legitimate, the records still must be complete; if they were not, the omission may indicate an illegal discharge and expose the ship and individuals to criminal proceedings. Do not reconstruct entries by guesswork. Locate shore receipts, tank soundings and transfer logs, interview the chief engineer and preserve the remaining ORB.
Rest hours. The records show 5 hours rest in 24 and 48 hours in 7 days, well below the MLC/STCW minimum of 10 hours in 24 and 77 hours in 7. The records say this is accurate, so fatigue is a real risk. Review the watch schedule, crew complement and actual hours; adjust watches and provide rest. Do not alter the records.
Emergency fire pump. The pressure and flow are below the required performance under SOLAS II-2. Repair or replace the pump, test it and obtain class attendance.
Immediate action. Raise a non-conformity under the SMS, conduct a root-cause investigation, prepare a corrective-action plan, notify flag/class/P&I, and request re-inspection. Cooperate with PSC but make no admissions.
2. Advise on communications with PSC, flag, charterers and P&I, and what evidence to preserve.
Read the worked answer
PSC. Acknowledge the findings in writing, present a realistic corrective-action plan and ask for re-inspection as soon as the items are closed. Record the inspector's name, the report reference and all correspondence. Do not argue or conceal; a cooperative approach is more likely to shorten the detention.
Flag and class. Notify the flag State and class of the detention and the corrective actions. Request attendance for the fire pump and any statutory verification. Keep the flag informed of the expected release time.
Charterers. Advise the delay immediately, state the facts and reserve the owner's rights. Do not accept off-hire or liability in correspondence. Issue a statement of facts and a protest, and record the times of the PSC inspection, detention, repair, testing and release.
Evidence. Preserve the ORB, rest-hour records, watch schedules, fire-pump test records, maintenance history, photographs, VDR data, crew statements, bunker and transfer receipts, and all PSC and class documents. Notify P&I and legal advisers immediately; communications may be privileged. Interview crew fairly, allow them to correct statements, and follow the MLC complaint procedure. Do not backdate, rewrite or destroy any record.
3. Assess the charterers' off-hire claim and state the master's documentary duties.
Read the worked answer
Under a typical time charter such as NYPE, the off-hire clause applies where a deficiency prevents the full working of the vessel. A PSC detention caused by the owner's failure to maintain the ship or its records can put the vessel off-hire for the period of loss of time. The charterers may also claim damages separately if they can prove a breach of the owner's due-diligence obligation and a resulting loss. However, off-hire is not automatic: the charterers must declare it and prove that the vessel was prevented from working. If the coal was not ready or the berth was unavailable in any event, the loss of time may be reduced or not established.
Master's duties. Record the time of arrival, NOR, PSC boarding, detention, each defect, repair, test, re-inspection and release. Issue a statement of facts and a letter of protest. Do not sign the charterers' off-hire statement or any admission without owner's authority. Keep the daily logs, PSC report and class attendance records. Send copies to the owner and P&I. The final assessment should be made by the owner's legal advisers under the actual charterparty, but the master's contemporaneous records will be the main evidence of the timeline and the cause of the delay.