Groupon, Guarantees, and a Referral Fee
Dr. Priya S. opens a new clinic and launches a website stating: 'We correct 90% of sciatica in six visits-guaranteed.' She sells a $49 'Lifetime Alignment Plan' through an online deal site; the fine print says the voucher expires in 30 days, is non-transferable, and is non-refundable. She also signs an agreement with a personal injury attorney: the attorney refers clients to Dr. S., and Dr. S. pays $150 per patient who retains the attorney. Her directory listing says 'Board Certified in Chiropractic' although she holds only an Iowa license and completed a 12-hour weekend seminar. A patient complains to the Board after being told the voucher would cover 'all care needed.' The clinic's website also displays a before-and-after posture photo with the caption 'typical result.'
1. Evaluate the website claim and the 'guaranteed' language under Iowa advertising rules.
Read the worked answer
Iowa advertising rules require truthful, non-misleading statements and prohibit guarantees of cure or results that cannot be substantiated. 'We correct 90% of sciatica in six visits-guaranteed' implies a predictable cure and a guarantee. Unless Dr. S. can produce reliable evidence and the claim is properly qualified, it is likely deceptive.
'Correct' is especially problematic because it suggests a permanent outcome. The 'typical result' photo also implies that the pictured outcome is representative; she needs substantiation and a disclaimer if it is not. The Board may treat this as false advertising and unprofessional conduct.
She should remove the percentage and guarantee, describe services accurately, and avoid implying that all patients will respond. Any testimonial or photo should be genuine, authorized, and accompanied by a clear statement of typical results.
2. Analyze the voucher terms and the attorney referral arrangement.
Read the worked answer
The voucher has multiple problems. Calling it a 'Lifetime Alignment Plan' while imposing a 30-day expiration is misleading; non-refundable and non-transferable terms may also violate consumer protection rules if not clearly disclosed. A voucher should state the specific services, expiration, refund policy, and any limits. Telling a patient it covers 'all care needed' compounds the deception.
The attorney referral arrangement is worse. Paying $150 per patient referred by an attorney is likely fee-splitting or a kickback prohibited by chiropractic ethics rules and possibly Iowa law. It creates an incentive to refer for financial gain rather than patient welfare. Dr. S. should terminate the arrangement, not disguise it as 'marketing,' and review all referral relationships.
She should also ensure that any business relationship with the attorney is disclosed to patients and complies with the rules on professional independence.
3. What should Dr. S. do about the 'Board Certified' statement?
Read the worked answer
The 'Board Certified in Chiropractic' statement is false if she holds only a state license and a weekend seminar certificate. Board certification must be accurately stated, with the certifying board named, and must not imply specialty status she does not have.
She should remove the claim immediately, correct directories and websites, and retain documentation of any legitimate certification. If she wants to advertise a credential, she must complete the recognized certifying process and comply with the Board's advertising rules. A 12-hour weekend seminar is not board certification.
The Board may consider the false statement as misleading advertising and as evidence of dishonesty. She should also review other credentials, such as 'diplomate' or 'fellow,' to ensure they are accurate and not misleading.