IAEM AEM study materials
IAEM AEM study resources

Debris Removal Before a Damage Declaration

IAEM AEM · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

Debris Removal Before a Damage Declaration

You are the recovery manager for a coastal town of 12,000. A Category 2 hurricane generated an estimated 180,000 cubic yards of vegetative debris and 40,000 cubic yards of construction and demolition debris, including asbestos-containing material from 22 pre-1980 homes. The town has a $4.1 million annual operating budget and a $900,000 debris line item. FEMA has not yet made a public assistance declaration; preliminary damage assessments are scheduled in six days. A contractor offers to begin removal within 24 hours at $28 per cubic yard with a 30-day payment term. Two historic structures on the town square are damaged but structurally repairable. Residents are placing debris in the right-of-way, some within 10 feet of fire hydrants. A local environmental group has documented debris being pushed into a tidal creek.

1. Can you authorize the contractor to start within 24 hours at $28 per cubic yard? What procurement and documentation conditions apply?

Read the worked answer

You can authorize only work that is immediately necessary to protect life, public health, and access; you cannot treat the offer as a blank check. Confirm the town's emergency procurement ordinance and the state's emergency purchasing rules. If sole-source emergency procurement is allowed, issue a written scope with unit prices, a not-to-exceed amount, load tickets, daily reports, and a requirement to separate vegetative from construction and demolition debris. $28 per cubic yard may be reasonable, but document the basis: compare with state contracts, nearby jurisdictions, or a cost estimate. A 30-day payment term may exceed the town's cash flow; check whether an emergency appropriation or short-term loan is needed before signing.

For FEMA eligibility, the work must be in the public right-of-way or on public property, documented before and after, and procured competitively when practicable. Even under emergency conditions, keep the procurement file, cost analysis, contract, invoices, load tickets, photos with GPS, and force-account labor. Do not start asbestos removal with a general debris contractor; that requires a licensed abatement contractor and separate disposal. Start only emergency access clearance and right-of-way debris that blocks roads, hydrants, or drainage; hold non-emergency demolition until the PDA and environmental reviews are complete.

2. How do you manage the asbestos, the creek, and the historic structures?

Read the worked answer

Treat the three issues separately because they trigger different legal and safety requirements. Asbestos: stop general debris handling of the 22 pre-1980 homes, notify the state environmental or health agency, require a licensed asbestos abatement contractor, wet the material, bag or wrap it, and dispose at an approved landfill. Do not allow asbestos-containing debris at a vegetative debris management site. Creek: immediately stop any pushing of debris into the tidal creek; that is a likely Clean Water Act and state wetland violation. Notify the state environmental agency, document the extent, and place a boom or silt fence if fuel or debris is migrating. Establish a debris management site on high ground away from wetlands and floodplains, with environmental review and leachate controls.

Historic structures: do not demolish the two town square buildings as debris. They are repairable, and if any federal funding or permit is involved, Section 106 consultation with the state historic preservation office is required. Stabilize them with temporary roofing or shoring, photograph conditions, and separate historic fabric from debris. Public messaging should explain why some debris is not being picked up immediately: hazardous materials and historic properties require special handling. Document all decisions and costs; environmental and historic compliance can be a reimbursement condition later.

3. What is your debris sequencing and public messaging in the first 72 hours?

Read the worked answer

Sequence by life safety and legal risk: first, clear access for emergency vehicles, fire hydrants, and drainage; second, remove household hazardous waste and asbestos-containing material; third, collect vegetative debris; fourth, collect construction and demolition debris. Do not mix streams. Set up a debris management site with a scale or load-ticket system, and use separate staging areas for vegetative, C&D, and hazardous waste. Keep a daily log of routes, tonnage or cubic yards, and photos.

Public messaging should be specific: separate vegetative debris from construction material; do not place debris within 10 feet of hydrants, mailboxes, or utility meters; do not put debris in the creek or storm drains; bag asbestos-like material and call a hotline. Give a pickup schedule by zone and a phone number. Explain that the town is documenting everything for possible reimbursement and that the PDA is in six days. Avoid promising federal reimbursement before a declaration. Ask residents to photograph their debris before placing it curbside. Coordinate with the environmental group rather than dismissing it; a public complaint can become a regulatory investigation, and early correction is cheaper than enforcement.