The Burned Sedan
At 02:15, firefighters extinguish a sedan fully involved in fire on a gravel pull-off. After overhaul, a charred body is found in the driver's seat, flexed, with no obvious skull fracture. The fire investigator notes the heaviest charring at the rear wheel well and a strong odor of gasoline near the filler neck, but the fuel door is closed. The vehicle is a 2012 sedan with a sealed electronic control module and a partially melted infotainment unit. Ambient temperature is -2°C, and the car is wet from hose streams. The body is badly charred but the hands are relatively spared. You are asked to process the vehicle at the scene because the tow company cannot take it until 08:00. A K-9 accelerant dog is available in 90 minutes.
1. What is your processing sequence for the vehicle and the body, given the 08:00 tow deadline and the K-9 arrival?
Read the worked answer
Treat the vehicle as a scene within a scene. First photograph the exterior 360°, then the interior through the windows before opening anything; record the body's position, flexed posture, and the seat's condition. Do not remove the body until the fire investigator and medical examiner have documented the scene, because the body's position relative to the seat and pedals matters. Sequence:
- Exterior and engine-compartment documentation.
- K-9 accelerant sweep at the perimeter and wheel well once the scene is safe, before hose water and overhaul disturb more.
- Collect accelerant samples from the heaviest charring area and a comparison sample from an unburned area.
- DNA swabs from the spared hands and any tissue before the body is bagged.
- Process the infotainment unit and ECM for digital data after the vehicle is transported.
Because the car is wet and the tow is at 08:00, cover open areas and document water exposure; do not let the tow operator move the body.
2. How do you preserve DNA and accelerant evidence on a water-soaked, heat-damaged car?
Read the worked answer
Water and heat compromise both. For DNA, the spared hands are the best source; swab them first with sterile swabs, air-dry, and package them separately from accelerant samples to prevent cross-contamination. Charred tissue may still yield DNA, but collect multiple samples and expect degradation; a reference sample is essential. For accelerant, use clean metal cans or arson-approved bags, fill headspace minimally, and collect a comparison sample from an unburned seat or trunk area. Water from hose streams can dilute accelerant, so sample the heaviest-charring area and any low point where runoff collected; note that the fuel door was closed and the filler-neck odor may indicate a separate pour. Keep accelerant and DNA samples physically separated in transport, and document all water exposure times.
3. What is the significance of relatively spared hands, and how do you document and collect from them?
Read the worked answer
Spared hands can indicate a defensive posture, that the hands were shielded by the body or lap, or that the fire was set elsewhere and the hands were not directly exposed. They are not proof of a self-inflicted or accidental fire. Document with close-up photographs of both hands, dorsal and palmar, with a scale, and note any thermal damage, soot, or blistering. Swab the hands for DNA and possible accelerant before bagging; use paper bags, not plastic, and secure them at the wrists. Collect fingernail clippings or swabs separately for each hand. If the hands are spared but the rest of the body is charred, the pattern is consistent with a low, localized fire source; correlate it with the seat and floor charring. Also collect a DNA reference from a non-charred site such as a tooth or bone if needed.