Commodity Dependence and Debt in Narania
Narania is a low-income country of 28 million people. GDP has grown at 6% a year for a decade, but GDP per capita is only $1,900 and the Gini coefficient has risen from 0.38 to 0.47. Copper accounts for 70% of exports and 35% of government revenue; copper prices fell 25% last year. External debt is 70% of GDP, and debt service absorbs 22% of government revenue. The currency depreciated 30% against the dollar, raising the cost of imported fuel and medicine. Inflation is 12%. Only 55% of children complete lower secondary school, and 38% of the population lacks safe water. The IMF offers a $1.2 billion loan conditional on removing fuel subsidies and reducing the fiscal deficit. The government must choose between accepting the programme, seeking debt relief, or expanding copper exports.
1. Distinguish between economic growth and economic development in Narania's case. Evaluate whether the country has achieved development.
Read the worked answer
Growth is the rise in real GDP; development is the improvement in living standards, health, education, inequality, and freedom. Narania has 6% growth but GDP per capita only $1,900, Gini rose from 0.38 to 0.47, school completion is 55%, and 38% lack safe water. Growth has not translated into broad development: the benefits are concentrated, possibly in copper, and the commodity price fall exposes vulnerability. The HDI would be low; the IHDI would be lower because of inequality. Development also requires environmental sustainability and resilience, which are undermined by debt service and depreciation. Therefore Narania has achieved growth but not development; it is experiencing uneven, commodity-dependent growth. A judgement should note that some SDGs may improve, but not enough.
2. Evaluate the IMF loan conditionality against alternative strategies such as debt relief and export diversification.
Read the worked answer
The IMF loan of $1.2bn offers liquidity but conditionality includes removing fuel subsidies, which is regressive because subsidies help the poor. It may stabilize the budget but raise inflation and social unrest. Debt relief would free revenue for health and education, but may not be enough without new finance. Export diversification is essential to reduce copper dependence and Dutch disease, but it takes time and requires industrial policy, infrastructure, and skills. The Prebisch-Singer hypothesis warns that commodity terms of trade may decline, so relying on copper is risky. A combined strategy is best: accept a modified IMF programme with social safeguards, seek debt restructuring, and use part of the savings for diversification. Conditionality should be sequenced so that subsidy reform is paired with targeted cash transfers.
3. Discuss how the depreciation of the currency affects progress towards the SDGs.
Read the worked answer
Depreciation raises the domestic price of imports, including fuel and medicine, which are essential for SDG 3 and SDG 6. Inflation at 12% erodes real incomes, increasing poverty (SDG 1) and food insecurity (SDG 2). Debt service is in foreign currency, so depreciation raises the real burden, diverting revenue from education (SDG 4) and water (SDG 6). On the other hand, a weaker currency can boost copper export revenues in domestic currency and improve competitiveness, supporting jobs. But copper export volume is supply-constrained and prices are set globally, so the boost is limited. The net effect on SDGs is negative unless the government protects essential imports, negotiates debt relief, and invests in diversification. Policy should prioritize targeted support for medicine and fuel for the poorest, not blanket subsidies.