The Late-Night Charter and the Driver's Hours
A coach operator has a charter departing at 22:00 on Friday, arriving at a seaside town 420 km away, with a planned return the following evening. The assigned driver, Marek, finished a school-run shift at 15:30 on Friday after starting at 06:00. He is scheduled to drive the outbound leg, rest at the destination hotel for about 9 hours, then drive the return leg on Saturday. The dispatcher argues the 9-hour hotel stop resets everything. Marek mentions he also did a 30-minute unloading job for another client at 16:15 on Friday and drove his own car 40 minutes home. The vehicle's tachograph shows the Friday school run totalled 8 hours 50 minutes of driving.
1. Identify the main legal risk in this plan and explain how the daily and weekly driving limits interact with the proposed schedule.
Read the worked answer
The core issue is that Marek has already accumulated substantial driving and duty time before the charter begins.
- Daily driving limit: Under EU/domestic rules (Regulation 561/2006 pattern), a driver may not exceed 9 hours of driving per day, extendable to 10 hours twice a week. Marek's Friday school run already used 8h50m. Adding the 420 km outbound leg (roughly 5–6 hours at coach speeds) would push him well past 10 hours on the same calendar day if the outbound leg counts toward Friday.
- Daily rest: A driver needs 11 hours of uninterrupted daily rest in each 24-hour period, reducible to 9 hours at most three times between weekly rests. A 9-hour hotel stop is only lawful if it is one of those reduced rests and is genuinely uninterrupted. The 30-minute unloading job at 16:15 and the 40-minute commute eat into the rest window and may count as other work or break the rest.
- Weekly limits: 56 hours driving in any week and 90 hours in any two consecutive weeks also constrain the plan.
Conclusion: The dispatcher's assumption that a 9-hour stop 'resets everything' is wrong. The plan likely breaches the daily driving limit and possibly the daily rest requirement. The operator should reassign the outbound leg to a rested second driver or delay departure so Marek gets a full 11-hour rest before driving.
2. Marek's 40-minute drive home in his own car - does it count? Explain how commuting and the 30-minute unloading job affect his rest and duty calculations.
Read the worked answer
This is a classic judgement point.
- Commuting: Time spent travelling between home and the normal workplace is generally not working time under the Road Transport Working Time Directive, provided the driver is not at the employer's disposal and can choose where to be. However, if the driver is travelling to a location other than his normal base, or is required to be available, it may count as working time. Marek driving his own car home is normally not duty time, but it does reduce the actual rest he obtains before the next shift - relevant to fatigue assessment even if not to the legal rest calculation.
- The 30-minute unloading job: This is other work for another client. It interrupts the rest period. If it falls within what would otherwise be the daily rest window, the rest is broken and must restart. It must be recorded and counts toward working time and possibly the 48-hour average week.
Conclusion: The commute is probably not duty time but is a fatigue factor; the unloading job is duty time and breaks rest. The dispatcher must treat the rest period as starting only after the 16:15 job finishes and the driver is free from all work obligations - not from 15:30.