Trade-Based Money Laundering Red Flags
You are a compliance officer at a bank that provides trade finance services. A customer, XYZ Trading Ltd, has been importing electronic goods from a supplier in a higher-risk jurisdiction. The bank has processed several letters of credit (LCs) for XYZ. Recently, you noticed that the invoices for the goods show prices significantly above market value (e.g., $500 per unit for a smartphone model that retails for $200). The shipping documents describe the goods as 'electronic components' but the quantity and weight do not match the invoice. The supplier and XYZ share the same registered address in an offshore jurisdiction. The shipping routes are circuitous, with goods transiting through multiple countries before reaching the destination. XYZ's account shows large payments to the supplier, and the goods are re-exported shortly after import to another country at a much lower price. The bank's trade finance team has not raised any concerns.
1. What trade-based money laundering (TBML) techniques are evident in this scenario? Explain each.
Read the worked answer
The scenario exhibits several TBML techniques:
- Over-invoicing: The invoice price ($500) is far above market value ($200), allowing the importer to transfer excess funds to the supplier, potentially moving illicit money out of the country.
- Misrepresentation of goods: The shipping documents describe 'electronic components' but the quantity and weight do not match the invoice, suggesting false description to conceal the true nature of goods or to justify the over-invoicing.
- Related parties: The supplier and XYZ share the same registered address, indicating a related-party transaction that may be used to manipulate prices and documents.
- Circuitous routing: The goods transit through multiple countries, which can obscure the origin and destination, making it harder to trace the money flow.
- Re-export at lower price: The goods are re-exported at a much lower price, which could be a way to move value back or to create a legitimate-looking paper trail. These techniques are classic indicators of TBML, where trade transactions are used to transfer value across borders.
2. What actions should the bank take in response to these red flags?
Read the worked answer
The bank should:
- Escalate internally: Immediately report the concerns to the MLRO and senior management.
- Conduct enhanced due diligence on XYZ Trading Ltd, including verifying the beneficial ownership of both XYZ and the supplier, and understanding the business relationship.
- Review all trade finance transactions involving XYZ for similar patterns.
- File a SAR with the FIU, detailing the suspicious trade activities.
- Consider suspending or terminating the relationship if the concerns cannot be resolved.
- Enhance monitoring of trade finance activities, including price verification and scrutiny of shipping documents.
- Train trade finance staff on TBML red flags and the importance of escalation.
- Document all actions and decisions. The bank should also consider whether to report to the relevant trade authorities.