Trust Account Shortage and a Deadline-Driven New Client
Ridgeway Legal is a three-lawyer firm. Its client trust ledger shows $48,250 owed to eight clients, but the pooled trust bank account balance is $45,900. The bookkeeper, who left in April, had been paying firm operating expenses directly from the trust account 'to save time' and recorded the payments as 'client costs.' A new client, Meridian Builders, arrives on 2 October with a 10-day deadline to file an appeal in a contract dispute. Meridian wants to pay a $7,500 flat fee and asks the firm to hold it 'until the work is done.' The intake paralegal runs a conflict check and finds that a partner had a 30-minute consultation with Meridian's opponent, Delta Supply, in 2022; no file was opened. The firm's engagement letter is a one-page template with no scope, no fee terms, and no conflict waiver.
1. What immediate steps must Ridgeway take to address the trust account shortage? Who is responsible?
Read the worked answer
Immediate steps. The $2,350 shortage is a trust-account violation. Ridgeway must (1) stop all trust-account disbursements except client payments; (2) reconcile the ledger and bank statements client by client; (3) deposit firm funds to restore the trust balance immediately; (4) identify which clients were shorted and correct their ledgers; (5) notify the bar regulator and affected clients as the rules require; (6) hire an independent bookkeeper or auditor; and (7) document every step.
Responsibility. The partners are ultimately responsible for trust compliance, even if the bookkeeper made the entries. Paying operating expenses from trust is commingling and conversion. The firm cannot use one client's funds to cover another's shortage; that compounds the breach. The bookkeeper may face civil or criminal liability, but the lawyers face discipline. The firm should also review whether the shortage was intentional or negligent; either way, self-reporting mitigates.
Prevention. Separate trust and operating accounts, dual signatures, monthly three-way reconciliation, and written procedures.
2. Can the firm take Meridian's case? Analyze the conflict and deadline.
Read the worked answer
Conflict. A 30-minute consultation can create a former-client relationship if Delta disclosed confidential information. The firm must determine whether the consultation was about the same contract dispute or a substantially related matter. If yes, Rule 1.9 bars representation adverse to Delta without informed consent. Even if no file was opened, the partner's memory and any notes matter. If the consultation was unrelated, the firm may proceed, but it should document screening and the partner's non-involvement.
Deadline. The 10-day appeal deadline is jurisdictional and cannot be missed. The firm should either (a) accept, open the file, calendar the deadline, and confirm in writing immediately, or (b) decline in writing the same day so Meridian can seek other counsel. It must not sit on the conflict check.
Decision. If the conflict is substantial, decline and return any fee. If not, obtain a written conflict waiver from Delta only if required, and screen the partner. The firm should not take the case merely because the fee is attractive.
3. What should the engagement letter include, and how should the $7,500 be handled?
Read the worked answer
Engagement letter. It should state the scope (appeal only, not the underlying trial), the client's responsibilities, the fee and costs, billing and payment terms, the trust-account treatment, the right to withdraw, communication expectations, and the conflict-check result. If the firm is not taking the case, send a declination letter instead.
Fee handling. Meridian wants the firm to hold the $7,500 'until the work is done.' That is an advance fee, not earned on receipt. It must be deposited in the trust account and withdrawn only as earned or at the agreed milestones. If the firm treats it as a flat fee earned on receipt, the engagement letter must say so and the jurisdiction must allow it; even then, unearned portions may be refundable. The firm should issue a trust receipt, keep a ledger, and not deposit the check into operating. If the case is declined, return the full amount promptly. Never use one client's advance fee to cover another's shortage.