Interfaith Week, Prayer Space and an Objection
During Interfaith Week, a Muslim student in fifth year asks to use an empty classroom for Friday prayers; 14 students sign a petition objecting that 'school time should not be used for religious worship' and that 'we don't do this for Christians'. The school already has a weekly Mass for Catholics and a prayer group. The principal asks the RE teacher to advise. The school is publicly funded but has a Catholic ethos; policy allows reasonable accommodation of religious practice. A local mosque has offered to send an imam to supervise, but child protection requires vetting. The proposed room is next to the library and has no washing facilities. The student says prayer takes 15 minutes at lunchtime.
1. Advise the principal on whether and how to grant the Friday prayer request.
Read the worked answer
Advise granting the request, because the school already accommodates Catholic worship and reasonable accommodation is required by religious freedom and equality. But grant it with conditions: lunchtime only, a fixed room, access to a nearby sink for washing, supervision by a vetted adult if the imam is to be present, no disruption to library users, and a review after four weeks. The petition is understandable but inconsistent: the school does not require anyone to attend Mass, and accommodation is not establishment. Catholic teaching supports this approach: Nostra Aetate 2-3 and Dignitatis Humanae affirm religious freedom and dialogue. Explain to the petitioners that fairness means making space for religious practice, not privileging one group. Record the decision and the conditions so that the precedent is clear. If the imam is only providing religious advice and not supervising students, the vetting question still needs a child protection check before he has any unsupervised access.
2. How should the RE teacher address the petition in class without turning it into a debate about Islam?
Read the worked answer
Focus on principles rather than on the Muslim student: religious freedom, reasonable accommodation, consistency and the common good. Use a structured discussion: 'What does fairness require when a school already has a Mass?' Ask students to distinguish between secular neutrality, which allows religious practice, and hostility, which suppresses it. Correct misinformation, such as the claim that Christians are not accommodated. Do not ask the Muslim student to defend Islam or to explain the petition. Allow students to disagree, but set a norm against contempt and stereotyping. Link the discussion to Catholic social teaching on human dignity and to the Church's teaching on interreligious dialogue. End with a short written reflection rather than a vote, because a vote would turn a matter of rights into a popularity contest.