Landslide on Day 4: 32 Passengers, One Road, One Flight
An inbound 32-passenger coach tour, eight days, sold as a fixed itinerary. At 06:30 on day 4 the guide in Mountain Town learns that a landslide has closed the only road to Coast City, where the group holds two prepaid, non-refundable nights and from where they fly home at 14:00 on day 6. The options are: a 7.5-hour coach detour (the driver has already driven 1 hour 40 today, and the company limit is 9 hours' driving in any 24 hours with 11 hours' rest); a 3-hour train from a station 40 minutes away, with 36 seats available but held only until 09:00; or a 4-hour charter boat under a small-craft weather advisory. Among the group, Mrs Fung, 78, walks with a stick; Mr Iqbal, 61, injects insulin and needs refrigeration; two passengers have paid a supplement for a Coast City harbour excursion; four have said they will refuse any boat. The coach company can supply a second driver in six hours.
1. It is 06:30. Which option do you take, and how do you justify it against the alternatives?
Read the worked answer
Decision: take the train, and confirm the seats before 07:00.
Test each option against three criteria - safety and legality, certainty of reaching the flight, and passenger welfare.
- Coach detour: 7.5 hours of driving added to 1 hour 40 already driven is 9 hours 10 minutes, over the company's 9-hour limit, with 11 hours' rest still required. It is not legal today without the second driver, who is six hours away. It also puts 32 people on a mountain road in the same weather system that caused the landslide. Reject.
- Charter boat: a small-craft weather advisory plus four passengers who have refused, plus a passenger with a walking stick boarding a small vessel. Safety and consent both fail. Reject.
- Train: 3 hours, 36 seats for 32 passengers, from a station 40 minutes away. Confirm and pay for all 36 seats now, by phone and in writing, and treat the 09:00 hold as a hard deadline. It sidesteps the road closure entirely and gets the group to Coast City with a buffer before day 6's 14:00 flight.
What makes this the right call The flight is the fixed point. Any plan that risks the flight is worse than an uncomfortable plan that protects it, and the train is the only option that is legal, weather-safe and gives a full recovery day.
2. How do you manage the two passengers with specific needs through the transfer, and how do you communicate the change to the whole group?
Read the worked answer
Mrs Fung (78, walking stick)
- Pre-book assistance at the station and seat her near the door, not at the far end of a carriage. Allow extra transfer time - the 40-minute station run must include loading and unloading, not just driving.
- Assign a named staff member or a fellow passenger to stay with her, and check she has her medication and a phone that works.
Mr Iqbal (insulin)
- Insulin must not freeze and should not sit in a hot coach hold. Ask him how he normally stores it and give him a cool bag with an ice pack, kept with him rather than in the luggage bay. Offer a refrigerator at the Coast City hotel on arrival.
- Ask discreetly, in private, not in front of the group. A medical need is not group information.
Communicating to the group
- Tell them at breakfast, in person, with the reason and the plan: road closed, train booked, departure time, arrival time, what happens to luggage.
- Frame it as a decision already made, not a debate. Give one person - the guide - as the point for questions, and resist a group vote; a vote on a safety decision splits the group and slows the transfer.
- Deal separately with the two who paid the harbour supplement and the four who dislike boats: the boat is not happening, so those conversations are about refunds and alternatives, not about changing the plan.
3. The group reaches Coast City. What must be documented, and what contractual and insurance points have to be handled?
Read the worked answer
Documentation
- A contemporaneous incident log: when the closure was confirmed, who was contacted, which options were priced, why the train was chosen, what was paid and by whom. Times and names, written the same day.
- Receipts for the 36 train seats, the station transfers and any extra baggage handling.
- The passengers' own accounts where relevant - particularly Mrs Fung's assistance and Mr Iqbal's medication storage, which should be recorded as provided, not assumed.
Contract and insurance
- The itinerary clause: most tour contracts allow itinerary change for force majeure (road closure, weather), but the operator still owes a duty of care and reasonable substitute arrangements. The train is that substitute; the original coach sector is not owed as a refund if the substitute is provided.
- The prepaid Coast City nights: the group still arrives, so the hotel is not owed a refund. The unused portion of the original road route may generate a supplier credit - pursue it, but do not promise it to passengers before it is confirmed.
- The harbour excursion supplement: the two passengers must be offered a refund or a replacement if the excursion cannot run, and told which within 24 hours.
- Insurance notification within the policy's window, with the incident log attached; the insurer will want to see that the decision was reasonable, documented and safety-led, not that it was cheapest.
The test of a good record Six months later, someone should be able to reconstruct why the train was chosen without asking the guide.