Six Percent, Seven Miles, and a Light Foot
A driver takes a loaded 5-axle tanker (80,000 lb) down a signed 6% grade, 7 miles long, at night in a 55 mph zone. At the top he shifts into 7th gear, which holds about 35 mph on the engine brake alone, but he leaves his foot lightly on the brake pedal the whole way because the engine brake is loud and he does not want to wake the town below. At mile 3 the truck creeps from 40 to 52 mph with the same pedal pressure. By mile 4 the pedal is on the floor and the truck is still accelerating; the pedal feels low and spongy, there is a hot, acrid smell, and the engine is at 1,900 rpm. The grade steepens ahead and a runaway truck ramp is signed for 1 mile.
1. Explain mechanically what is happening to the brakes between mile 3 and mile 4, and why pushing harder is producing less stopping force.
Read the worked answer
This is brake fade, and it is a heat problem rather than a pressure problem.
A light, continuous application keeps the shoes in contact with the drums for miles. That converts the truck's potential energy into heat faster than the drums and the airflow can shed it, so drum temperature climbs steadily. Three things follow:
- Drum expansion. The drums grow away from the shoes, so the same pushrod travel produces less shoe force. The pedal gets longer and softer for exactly this reason.
- Lining fade. The friction material overheats and its coefficient of friction drops. The shoes are pressing hard but gripping less, which is why the pedal on the floor buys almost nothing.
- Outgassing and smell. Resins in the lining vaporize; that is the acrid smell, and the gas layer between lining and drum further reduces friction.
The trap is that the driver's natural response - more pressure, held longer - adds more heat and accelerates the fade. At the point the pedal is on the floor and the truck is still accelerating, the service brakes are no longer capable of absorbing the energy of the descent. Heat also degrades seals and can start a wheel fire.
2. Identify the specific decisions made at the top of the grade that led here, and describe the technique that should have been used.
Read the worked answer
Mistake 1 - gear choice. Seventh gear was only good for about 35 mph on the engine brake, which sounds fine, but he then drove faster than that, so the engine brake could never hold the truck. The correct gear is one that holds the target speed on the engine brake alone, with the service brakes cool and available. A useful check is to descend in or near the gear that was needed to climb the grade.
Mistake 2 - continuous light drag. A light, steady pedal for miles is the worst technique for drum brakes. It never lets the drums cool, and it hides the fade until it is advanced.
Mistake 3 - not using the engine brake. Turning off the retarder to be quiet removed the one system that does not fade.
Correct technique: slow to the target speed before the grade begins, select the gear, use the engine brake or retarder as the primary control, and use the service brakes in snubs - a firm application that sheds 5 to 8 mph, then fully release and let the drums cool - never a light drag and never fanning. If the truck cannot hold the speed on the retarder alone, the gear is too high.
3. What are his options in the next mile, and how should he choose between them?
Read the worked answer
The truck is already in runaway condition: it is accelerating on a steepening grade with no effective service brakes, at 1,900 rpm, with a ramp signed within 1 mile. The options are:
- Runaway truck ramp. This is now the primary choice. Ramps are built for exactly this - a loaded truck with failed brakes at speed. Use it, even though it will damage the truck and the load. A tanker adds a rollover and spill risk, but a controlled arrest in an engineered gravel bed is far safer than a 7-mile descent with no brakes.
- Progressive downshifting. Only if the speed is still low enough that a downshift will not over-rev the engine. At 1,900 rpm and accelerating, one more downshift may be past the governor and can float valves or scatter a clutch. It is a supplement, not the plan.
- Engine brake at maximum - already on; no further help available.
- Uphill grade or a side road - worth taking if one appears before the ramp, because gravity will help stop him.
What he should not do is ride it out hoping the ramp is not needed, or coast in neutral. Get the hazards on, keep steering, aim for the ramp early, and commit once he is lined up rather than trying to abort at the last moment.