Positive Spore Tests and Missing Sterilization Records
The River North office has two autoclaves. Autoclave B’s weekly spore test is positive on March 4 and again on March 11. The office manager tells the staff to “re-run it; if it comes back negative, keep using B.” Staff used B to sterilize instruments for 14 patients between the two tests. The office keeps only a folder of spore results; there are no load logs, no maintenance log, and no written policy for a positive test. A patient calls after reading a CDC webpage and asks whether she was exposed. The dentist is unsure whether to tell patients, retest, or simply switch to Autoclave A. The practice is due for a routine inspection in two weeks. No instruments were visibly contaminated, and the office uses pouches.
1. What must the dentist do after the March 4 positive spore test, and what changes after the March 11 positive? Address autoclave use, reprocessing, and patient notification.
Read the worked answer
A positive biological indicator means the load may not have been sterilized. On March 4, Autoclave B should have been removed from service immediately, not re-run and used again. The office should have identified instruments processed since the last validated negative test, reprocessed them before use, and used Autoclave A only after confirming A’s own monitoring. A single negative retest does not instantly clear B; it must be repaired or adjusted as needed and then pass appropriate retesting before returning to service.
The March 11 positive confirms a persistent failure. B must remain out of service. The office should determine whether any patient was exposed to improperly processed instruments, document the investigation, and notify patients when the risk assessment shows a need. Notification should be based on the actual breach, not on fear of bad publicity. The dentist should follow current CDC and Illinois Department of Public Health guidance and consult the office’s infection-control expert.
2. Identify the recordkeeping deficiencies and explain how they should be corrected.
Read the worked answer
The office lacks load logs, maintenance records, and a written positive-test policy. Those records are not optional clutter: they show which instruments were processed, when, and whether the sterilizer was functioning. The office should create a log for each load (date, sterilizer, cycle, operator, indicator result), a spore-test log, a maintenance and repair log, and a written policy stating that a positive spore test removes the unit from service. Staff should be trained and the training documented. Records should be retained for the period required by the Act and rules and should be producible on inspection. Correcting the records now must be truthful; backfilling logs with invented times or results would create a separate integrity problem.
3. A staff member suggests charging the 14 patients for repeat visits to reprocess or replace instruments. Analyze that suggestion.
Read the worked answer
The repeat visits would be caused by the office’s sterilization failure, not by patient error. Billing patients for corrective care would be inappropriate and could raise concerns about false claims or unprofessional conduct. The office should waive charges for the corrective visits, document what was done, and treat the cost as a practice expense. If insurance is billed, the claim must accurately describe the service and the reason; billing a “new” procedure to conceal a redo would be improper.