The Backdated Survey and the Unlicensed Seal
A licensed Illinois land surveyor's office is finishing an ALTA/NSPS survey for a commercial sale. The seller's attorney asks the surveyor to date the survey 14 months earlier, before a new 40-by-60-foot equipment shed was built without a permit, and to leave the shed off the drawing because the buyer's lender 'only wants a clean survey.' The surveyor is on vacation; a survey technician who is not licensed has already applied the surveyor's digital seal to the drawing and transmitted it. The attorney says the surveyor 'always approves this stuff when he gets back.' The technician also changed the survey date in the CAD file to match the attorney's request. The client has not yet closed on the sale.
1. Identify the regulatory and ethical violations in the technician's actions and the attorney's request.
Read the worked answer
The technician is practicing land surveying without a license and using the surveyor's seal without authority. Under the Illinois Professional Land Surveyor Act, 225 ILCS 330, only a licensed professional land surveyor may sign and seal survey work, and the seal may be applied only to work prepared by the surveyor or under the surveyor's direct supervision. Backdating the survey is a false statement of fact, and omitting the shed is a material misrepresentation, especially on an ALTA/NSPS survey. The attorney's request to conceal the shed and change the date is an ethics problem, not a client-service request. The surveyor cannot ratify the technician's seal after the fact without reviewing and accepting responsibility for the work.
2. What should the surveyor do immediately upon returning?
Read the worked answer
On returning, the surveyor should immediately withdraw the transmitted drawing, remove the seal, and notify the client and attorney in writing that the date and depiction must be accurate. The surveyor should review the field data, determine whether the work was performed under direct supervision, and if not, re-perform or properly supervise the survey before sealing. The shed must be shown unless the applicable standard and client scope explicitly exclude it; even then, the exclusion should be stated, not hidden. The surveyor should document the requests and the correction. If the false sealed drawing has already been relied on, the surveyor should correct it with all recipients and consider legal and regulatory reporting obligations.
3. May the surveyor accept the attorney's assurance that the surveyor 'always approves this stuff'?
Read the worked answer
No. The seal is personal and cannot be delegated by convenience or ratified by a statement that the surveyor always approves. Approval requires knowledge of the work and professional judgment. The date on a survey is a factual representation of when the fieldwork or certification occurred, not a cosmetic field. Accepting the attorney's assurance would make the surveyor complicit in misleading the lender and buyer. The proper response is to decline the change, explain the standards, and offer a correctly dated survey that shows the shed. The surveyor should also remind the office that unlicensed staff may not apply the seal or alter a sealed drawing.