The Unlicensed Assistant, the Instagram Ad, and the Cash Deposit
You are the designated managing broker for a 180-unit apartment community in Naperville. Your leasing staff includes Priya, licensed three weeks ago and sponsored by your brokerage, and Marcus, an unlicensed "leasing assistant" hired six months ago. On Monday four things happen. (1) Marcus takes a call and quotes $1,750 for unit 402, then adds that the owner will "probably take $1,650 on a 14-month term." (2) Marcus emails a blank lease form to a prospect with a note to sign and return it. (3) Priya posts an Instagram ad reading "2BR/2BA - $1,750 - call Priya, 555-0142" with no brokerage name. (4) A prospect hands Priya $2,150 cash as a holding deposit, and Priya puts it in her personal checking account until Thursday so it "doesn't get lost." The owner also pays Priya a $50 bonus per signed lease, directly.
1. Evaluate Marcus's two actions. What may an unlicensed assistant lawfully do in this office, and what is the broker's exposure?
Read the worked answer
Neither action is permissible as done.
- Quoting the published $1,750 from an approved rate sheet is ministerial and generally acceptable for an unlicensed assistant. Improvising a negotiating range ("probably $1,650 on 14 months") is negotiating lease terms - a licensed activity under the Illinois Real Estate License Act. It also binds the owner to a position you never authorized.
- Emailing a blank lease for signature crosses from clerical into transaction handling. Preparing or facilitating execution of lease documents is licensee work; Marcus may deliver a lease already prepared by you or Priya, but not originate the paperwork or instruct a prospect to sign.
Permissible for Marcus: answering and routing calls, scheduling showings, giving factual information from an approved sheet (unit size, amenities, published rent), delivering prepared documents, filing, and data entry - with no advice, no negotiation, and no discussion of terms or alternatives.
Broker exposure: aiding unlicensed practice is a disciplinary matter against your license, not just Marcus's employment status. Fix immediately: a written scope-of-duties memo, retitle the role, and route every pricing exception and lease document to Priya or you.
2. Priya's Instagram post: identify the defect, explain the rule behind it, and rewrite the ad.
Read the worked answer
Defect: the advertisement omits the licensed name of the sponsoring brokerage. Advertising by a sponsored licensee must identify the brokerage; a "blind" ad naming only the agent is noncompliant, and "call Priya" implies she is the responsible party when she is not. Instagram counts as advertising - format is irrelevant.
Additional exposure: if the rent figure or terms could change before the post is taken down, the ad also risks being misleading. Every ad must be accurate as of posting and updated or removed when terms change.
Rewrite: "2BR/2BA apartment - $1,750/month, 12-month lease - [Brokerage Legal Name], 555-0142. Equal Housing Opportunity."
Process fix: pull the post now, adopt a written advertising policy (brokerage name, licensed agent name, no unapproved price or concession claims, broker review before posting), and keep a copy of every ad with its posting dates. Priya should not advertise independently until the policy is signed off.
3. Analyze the $2,150 cash handling and the owner's direct $50 bonus to Priya. What must change?
Read the worked answer
The cash deposit: money taken from a prospective tenant - whether called a holding deposit, application fee, or security deposit - is trust money. It must be turned over to the broker and deposited into the brokerage's designated escrow/special account. Putting it in a personal checking account is commingling and, even for two days, conversion risk; if the deal falls apart and the money is gone, the broker is liable. Correct handling: issue a dated receipt to the payer, log the receipt, and deposit per the brokerage's written escrow procedure. A holding deposit should also be documented in writing stating whether it is refundable and on what conditions, so there is no dispute later.
The $50 bonus: compensation for licensed leasing activity must be paid to the sponsoring brokerage, not to the individual licensee. Priya accepting payment directly from the owner violates the Act and creates an undisclosed-compensation problem; it also means the owner may be treating her as an independent actor when she is not.
Fix: notify the owner in writing that all compensation flows to the brokerage, route the bonus through the broker's books, and distribute to Priya under her independent-contractor agreement. Escrow the cash today and document the chain of custody.