Alarm on Three, Tenant on Four
At 02:10 on a Tuesday, a security officer is on the ground floor of a four-story, 60,000-square-foot office building. The fire alarm activates on the third floor. The panel shows a smoke detector in a third-floor server room and a waterflow alarm on the same floor. He smells an acrid, electrical odor in the lobby stairwell. The building has two enclosed stairwells; the elevators are in the center core. A tenant from the fourth floor, a 60-year-old man in a bathrobe, comes down the stairs and says, 'I'm not going outside, it's cold and it's probably a drill.' The officer has a radio, a flashlight, and a 10-pound ABC extinguisher. The fire department has not arrived. There is no other guard on duty.
1. What are the officer's immediate priorities, and what should he avoid doing?
Read the worked answer
His first priority is to call 911 and give the address, the panel location, the smoke detector and waterflow signals, the electrical odor, and the building occupancy. He should then start a general evacuation by the public address system or by directing people to the stairwell that is farthest from the odor, and he should not use the elevators. Before opening any door he should feel it for heat and stay low if there is smoke. He should not enter the server room alone to investigate. A waterflow alarm means sprinkler water is moving, and an electrical odor suggests energized equipment, smoke, and possible shock. A 10-pound ABC extinguisher is rated for electrical fires but can damage equipment and is not a substitute for evacuation. He should go to the designated meeting point, account for occupants as best he can, meet the fire department, and provide the panel information and keys. If smoke conditions worsen, he should evacuate himself and not re-enter.
2. How should the officer handle the tenant who refuses to leave?
Read the worked answer
He should treat the refusal as a persuasion and documentation problem, not a physical-control problem. He should identify himself, say the alarm is on the third floor with an electrical odor and is not confirmed as a drill, and ask the man to come with him by the safe stairwell. He should acknowledge the cold and offer a practical alternative, such as waiting in a warm vehicle or asking the fire department to meet him, but he should not argue about whether it is a drill. He should not use force unless there is an immediate threat to life and no safer option; physically dragging a 60-year-old man in a bathrobe down stairs creates injury and liability risk. If the man still refuses, the officer should note his exact location and statement, tell the fire department on arrival, and continue the evacuation. The fire department has the authority to order evacuation. The officer should document the refusal and the warning given.
3. Under what conditions, if any, should the officer use the extinguisher or enter the server room?
Read the worked answer
He should use the extinguisher only for a small, incipient fire that he can see, with a clear exit behind him, and only if he has been trained and the extinguisher is appropriate. For an energized server room, a CO2 or clean-agent extinguisher is preferable; an ABC dry chemical can be used on electrical equipment but may cause collateral damage and reduces visibility. He should not enter the server room alone at 02:10 with an unknown fire and a waterflow alarm. If the door is hot, he should not open it. If he sees only a small trash-can fire in the lobby, he can use PASS, but the server room is a different risk. The priority is evacuation, 911, and protecting the sprinkler and electrical systems by closing doors. He should record what he saw and did and let the fire department handle the room.