Friday Night Hit: A Clearance Note, Symptoms on Monday, and a Coach's Text
You teach health and sit on the concussion oversight team at a high school of 1,600 students. On Friday the starting quarterback, a junior, took a helmet-to-helmet hit, was removed from the game, and was seen at urgent care on Saturday. The note says cleared to return to activity and is signed by a physician assistant. On Monday in first period he tells you the lights hurt, he has a headache, and he feels slow, and asks to put his head down. The coach texts you: he is cleared, right, I need him at practice tomorrow. The athlete says his parents think it is just a headache and do not want him missing film sessions. Your district protocol, adopted under the Illinois Youth Sports Concussion Safety Act, requires removal from play when a concussion is suspected, written clearance by a provider named in board policy before return to athletics, and a return-to-learn plan before the student resumes full academics.
1. State your immediate actions in first period and your assessment of the clearance note.
Read the worked answer
Immediate actions: do not send him to the locker room, the weight room, or the bus alone. Move him to a quiet, dim space with supervision, notify the nurse or athletic trainer and an administrator, contact the parent or guardian today with the specific symptoms observed rather than a general concern, and document on the district concussion form with times. I would also tell the coach directly that the student is not practicing until the protocol is satisfied.
On the note: it is a starting point, not a permission slip. Two questions decide its weight. First, does board policy list physician assistants among the providers who may clear a student, or does it require a physician or neuropsychologist? Second, does the note address return to learn, or only activity? Many notes say return to activity and say nothing about academic accommodations. Even a valid clearance does not override symptoms that appeared or worsened afterward, and Monday's headache and light sensitivity are new information. My job is to report and enforce, not to diagnose or to overrule a clinician.
2. Write the return-to-learn progression you would request, with specific accommodations and decision rules.
Read the worked answer
I would request a staged plan managed by the oversight team, with the athletic trainer handling return to play separately. Stage one is a short period of reduced cognitive and physical activity at home, typically a day or two, not prolonged dark-room rest, which current guidance no longer supports. Stage two is partial days with a reduced workload: one task at a time, no tests or quizzes, frequent breaks, a pass to the nurse, sunglasses or a hat permitted, preferential seating away from fluorescent glare and noise, and no physical education. Stage three is full days with continued academic accommodations and no athletics. Stage four is full academics with accommodations removed gradually, and only after that does the graduated return-to-play protocol begin, with 24 hours between steps and no contact until the later stages.
Decision rule: a meaningful increase in symptoms, or symptoms that return, means dropping back a stage and re-checking with the provider. I would set up a brief daily symptom check with the trainer or nurse and route teacher notifications through the counselor, sharing only the accommodations and not the diagnosis.
3. How do you answer the coach's text and the parents' reluctance, and what are the limits of your authority?
Read the worked answer
To the coach I would reply factually and without argument: he has symptoms in class today, under the district protocol he is not participating in practice until the return-to-learn plan is in place and the clearance is verified against board policy, and the athletic trainer and athletic director are now involved. I would not debate the game plan or the depth chart, because the moment the conversation becomes about winning, the protocol looks like an opinion instead of board policy.
To the parents I would explain that a headache after a hit is a symptom, not a nuisance, and that returning a still-symptomatic brain to contact risks a longer recovery and, with a second impact, far worse. I would connect them to the athletic trainer and the treating provider and give them the written protocol so it is not me talking.
Limits: I cannot clear him, cannot overrule the provider, and cannot diagnose. What I can do is report symptoms, request and enforce academic accommodations, document, and escalate when the plan is not followed.