Leaf to Label
Aji Tea Garden, a four-hectare small holding near Dibrugarh, produces about 30,000 kg of green leaf a year and sells all of it to a bought-leaf factory at ₹22 per kg. A cousin in Guwahati argues that the family should process and pack part of its own tea. The conversion ratio is about 4.5 kg of green leaf to 1 kg of made tea; processing at a nearby factory costs ₹40 per kg of made tea and packaging costs ₹60 per kg. The cousin proposes spending ₹1.8 lakh on pouches, labels and a small storage room, and selling at ₹480 per kg through Instagram and tourist shops. Local wholesale made tea sells at about ₹220 per kg. The family has ₹90,000 in savings and no food-safety certification. Tourists visit the district mainly between October and April.
1. Estimate the cost per kg of packaged tea and the break-even volume at ₹480 per kg if fixed costs are ₹1.8 lakh a year. Is the plan financially plausible?
Read the worked answer
Variable cost per kg of made tea:
- Green leaf: 4.5 kg × ₹22 = ₹99
- Processing: ₹40
- Packaging: ₹60
- Total: ₹199 per kg
Contribution: ₹480 − ₹199 = ₹281 per kg. Break-even: ₹1,80,000 ÷ ₹281 ≈ 641 kg a year.
Total made tea available = 30,000 ÷ 4.5 ≈ 6,667 kg, so 641 kg is under 10% of output. On paper the plan works, but only if that volume can actually be sold at ₹480. 641 kg is about ₹3.08 lakh of retail sales, or roughly 90 kg a month during the seven-month tourist season. That is a real marketing task, not a formality.
The calculation also omits food-safety certification, shipping pouches to online buyers, spoilage and the labour cost of packing. If sales reach only 400 kg, contribution is ₹1,12,400 against ₹1,80,000 fixed cost - a loss of ₹67,600. The plan is financially plausible only as a tested pilot, not as a full upfront spend.
2. What evidence should the family gather before accepting the cousin's market assumptions, and which channel should it test first?
Read the worked answer
The assumption that needs evidence is demand at ₹480, not the cost calculation. The family should gather:
- Pre-orders or expressions of interest from at least 30 individual buyers.
- Conversations with five tourist shops and two hotels about shelf price, margin and returns policy.
- A price test: compare ₹480 with ₹380 and ₹550, and note the volume response.
- Seasonal data: how many tourists pass nearby, and what they buy as gifts.
- Repeat-purchase evidence, because one-time tourist sales do not build a year-round business.
Channel logic: tourist shops give footfall but demand a trade margin of 25–35% and may return unsold stock; Instagram gives higher margin but needs shipping, trust and regular content. Start with two or three tourist shops on consignment plus a small online pre-order page. Sell the rest of the made tea through the existing wholesale channel so that fixed costs are not loaded onto the retail experiment. Before any retail sale, apply for food-safety registration.
3. The family can spend only ₹90,000 now. Recommend a phased plan and state the decision rule for scaling up.
Read the worked answer
Do not spend ₹1.8 lakh before demand is proven. A phased plan:
Phase 1 (₹35,000–₹40,000, three months): pack 200 kg in plain food-grade pouches with a simple label; complete food-safety registration; place stock in two tourist shops on consignment and take pre-orders on social media; keep all remaining leaf in the wholesale channel.
Phase 2 (only if Phase 1 sells): use the revenue to fund a second 300 kg batch, improve labels and add a second outlet. Negotiate the processing charge in advance and keep a record of rejection and spoilage.
Phase 3: spend on the storage room and larger packaging run only when repeat orders from shops exceed 50 kg a month.
Decision rule: scale up only if at least 70% of the first 200 kg sells within 90 days at an average realisation above ₹430 per kg, and at least two shops reorder. If those thresholds are missed, the family should keep the wholesale channel and treat packing as a small seasonal sideline rather than a main business.