Priya's First 401(k), a 25% Credit Card and Two Pitches
Priya is 22 and started her first full-time job three months ago at a salary of $52,000. Her employer offers a 401(k) with a 50% match on the first 6% of pay she contributes; the match vests only after two years of service, and she intends to stay at least three. Her only savings is $4,000 in an account paying 0.40% APY. She also has $2,300 on a credit card at 24.99% APR and pays $75 a month. In about 14 months she expects to buy a used car and wants $5,000 for a down payment. A coworker is pushing her to move the $4,000 into a target-date retirement fund because 'the market always beats 8% a year,' while her cousin is pitching a crypto token that 'pays 18% monthly, guaranteed.' Priya covers her bills each month but adds nothing to savings beyond the $4,000 already there.
1. Put Priya's next dollars in order and justify each step with numbers.
Read the worked answer
1. Capture the full match. 6% of $52,000 is $3,120 a year, and the 50% match adds $1,560 - an instant 50% return, before any market movement. It costs her about $260 a month pre-tax (roughly $200 net after income tax). No other use of a dollar comes close, and a missed year cannot be bought back later. Caveat: the match is on a two-year cliff vest, so if she leaves before two years she forfeits it; she says she will stay three, so the risk is acceptable, but she should not count the match as hers until it vests.
2. Kill the credit card. $2,300 at 24.99% costs about $575 a year and $48 a month. Paying it off is a guaranteed, risk-free, after-tax return of 25% - strictly better than a stock fund's expected return and infinitely better than 0.40%. Fund it from the $4,000: $4,000 − $2,300 = $1,700 remaining.
3. Keep a starter buffer. $1,000–1,700 in high-yield savings, not invested. Her car is a used one and a $900 repair should not become a credit card balance.
4. Car down payment. $5,000 in 14 months. Starting from the remaining buffer, she needs roughly $235–280 a month - which is almost exactly what she was throwing at the card and the interest she no longer pays, plus the ~$57/month of tax saved by the 401(k) contribution.
Order matters because the steps fund each other: the match is free money, the card payoff frees $75 a month plus $48 of interest, and both pay for the car fund.
2. Where should the car down-payment money sit, and why not in the target-date fund?
Read the worked answer
In cash equivalents matched to a 14-month date: a high-yield savings account, a 12-month CD timed to mature before the purchase, or Treasury bills. The two criteria are capital stability and liquidity on a known date.
Why not the target-date fund:
- Horizon mismatch. A target-date fund for someone retiring around 2065 runs roughly 90% equities. Equity funds have fallen 20%+ within a single year more than once this century. A 20% drop on $5,000 is $1,000 lost, and she cannot 'wait for the recovery' when the car is needed in month 14.
- Account type. If the target-date fund is inside a 401(k) or IRA, withdrawing for a car triggers tax on the withdrawal (and generally a 10% early-distribution penalty on an IRA), and many plans do not permit in-service withdrawals at all. The money may not be reachable.
- Sequence risk vs. average return. The often-quoted '8% a year' is an average over decades; it says nothing about a specific 14-month window, which can be negative even in a good decade.
- Goal separation. Mixing retirement money with a car fund is how people raid retirement for depreciating assets. Two labelled accounts prevent it.
At realistic rates a high-yield account or CD pays 4%+ with no principal risk - on $5,000 that is about $200–250 of interest over the period, which is the entire upside available without gambling the down payment.
3. Evaluate the coworker's claim and the cousin's crypto pitch. What should Priya actually do with each?
Read the worked answer
'The market always beats 8% a year' - false as stated. The word always is the tell. Long-run US equity averages have been in the 7–10% range before inflation, but returns are not evenly distributed: a decade can be flat or negative, and an individual's result depends entirely on entry and exit dates. A target-date fund is still a sensible default for her retirement money, for three reasons: automatic diversification, automatic rebalancing to a more conservative mix as the date approaches, and low effort. She should check the expense ratio - target-date funds range from roughly 0.08% to over 0.6%, and on a small balance the difference compounds. Correct use: retirement contributions go there and stay for decades; the car fund does not.
'18% monthly, guaranteed' - a mathematical and behavioural red flag. 1.18 raised to the 12th power is about 7.1× in one year: $1,000 becomes roughly $7,100, and $10,000 becomes $71,000. No legitimate business sustains that; returns that high are paid from new depositors' money. The red flags stack: a guaranteed return, a family/referral channel, pressure and urgency, no registration or prospectus, and no clear explanation of where the yield comes from.
What she should do: decline, and decline the referral request too. If she wants any crypto exposure, cap it at money she could lose entirely - and she has none to spare while carrying a 25% card. Her real portfolio decision this year is boring and far more valuable: capture the match, clear the card, and hold the car money in cash.