Conveyor Jam Near Miss and Interlock Bypass
At a food-processing plant near Nagaon, a 7.5 kW three-phase motor drives a 12 m inclined conveyor. A plastic crate jammed at the head pulley during the night shift. The cleaner lifted the interlocked guard, which had been bypassed with a cable tie for three weeks because the interlock switch was 'nuisance tripping', and tried to pull the crate out with a hook while the conveyor was still running. A fitter saw the cleaner's sleeve catch on the belt and hit the local stop. No one was injured, but the incident was reported as a near miss. The area noise level is 93 dB(A) over an eight-hour shift, welding fumes from a nearby maintenance job are visible, and the floor is wet near the drive. The plant has a written safety policy but no permit-to-work system, and the maintenance electrician says lockout is 'not practical' because production targets are high. The manager asks for a proportionate response within two weeks.
1. Identify the uncontrolled hazards and failures in the hierarchy of controls. Distinguish immediate actions from engineering and administrative controls.
Read the worked answer
Machine hazards: the head pulley guard was removed, the interlock was defeated with a cable tie, the cleaner worked while the conveyor was running, and the hook was unsuitable for clearing a jam. Management failures: no permit-to-work, no lockout, no risk assessment, production pressure and a tolerated bypass for three weeks. Health hazards: noise at 93 dB(A) for eight hours exceeds the 90 dB(A) eight-hour limit; welding fume is visible; the wet floor is a slip hazard. Apply the hierarchy: eliminate the jam source by improving the transfer chute; engineer fixed guards, a captive-key interlock that cannot be tied, a remote clearing tool, local exhaust ventilation, an acoustic enclosure and drainage/anti-slip flooring; then administrative controls such as PTW, LOTO, training, rotation and housekeeping; PPE is last. Do not rely on gloves near a rotating pulley - loose gloves can increase entanglement risk. Immediate actions: stop the job, restore the interlock, lock out, clean the floor and start fume extraction.
2. Draft a lockout and permit-to-work sequence for clearing the jam. Include verification of isolation and release of stored energy.
Read the worked answer
Permit-to-work and LOTO sequence: (1) raise a PTW and notify production; (2) identify all energy sources - 415 V electrical supply, gravity from the raised conveyor, any pneumatic tensioner and stored spring energy; (3) shut down normally and isolate the correct breaker, not just the local stop; (4) apply a personal lock and tag, and remove the key; (5) attempt a start to confirm the local control is dead; (6) verify absence of voltage with a tested meter; (7) release stored energy - lower and block the conveyor, release air pressure; (8) clear the jam with a non-entangling tool while standing clear of the nip; (9) remove tools, restore the guard and interlock, and confirm the area is clear; (10) remove locks and tags under the permit, then test run and close the permit. The cable-tie bypass must be removed and the switch repaired or replaced. If maintenance mode is needed, use a deliberate hold-to-run, limited-speed mode with a key, not an improvised bypass.
3. Evaluate the noise and welding-fume exposures and recommend controls. Explain why a written policy alone is not adequate evidence of control.
Read the worked answer
Noise: 93 dB(A) for 8 h is an 8-hour dose of about 200% against the 90 dB(A) criterion (allowable time at 93 dB(A) is about 4 h with a 3 dB exchange rate). Engineering controls come first: enclose or damp the drive and head pulley, maintain bearings, isolate vibration and relocate the cleaner's station. Until then, limit exposure time, rotate staff, provide hearing protection with a suitable attenuation rating, mark the area and arrange audiometric testing. Welding fume: use local exhaust ventilation at the arc, keep the welder out of the plume, provide respiratory protection for residual fume, and require a hot-work permit with a fire watch. Wet floor: repair drainage, use anti-slip mats and clean spills immediately. Record the near miss, investigate root causes, and verify corrective actions within the two-week deadline; a written policy alone is not evidence of control.