The Boy With the Copper Bag
You are a guard at a hardware shop with an attached godown in Guwahati. At 19:30 you see a boy of about 16 walking out with a cloth bag. Inside are copper fittings and wire worth roughly ₹4,800, taken from a shelf near the back door. He says an adult told him to carry the bag out and has run away. Your colleague wants to slap him, phone his father, recover ₹2,000 as a 'fine' and let him go, arguing that the police will take hours and the owner will be angry about the paperwork. The owner is out of station; his son is reachable on the phone. There is no CCTV covering that corner. The bag also contains a school identity card. The shop's cash box and the day's collection are in the counter drawer behind you.
1. What legal authority do you have over the boy, and what are its limits?
Read the worked answer
A private security guard is not a police officer and has no police powers of arrest.
- The only basis for holding him is the citizen's-arrest provision of the BNSS (s.35, the successor to s.43 CrPC), which allows a private person to detain someone committing a cognizable, non-bailable offence and to hand him over to the police without unnecessary delay. Theft of ₹4,800 is cognizable but ordinarily bailable, so detention is justified only for the short time needed to call the police and inform the owner - not for hours in a back room.
- Force must be the minimum needed to prevent escape. No slap, no tying, no beating: that is hurt and wrongful confinement under the BNS, and you become the accused.
- You cannot fine, settle or compound. Taking ₹2,000 to release him is extortion, and accepting money makes you a party to it.
- He is 16 - a juvenile under the JJ Act 2015. The police must be informed, he must not be kept with adult offenders, and only the Juvenile Justice Board decides the case. The Child Welfare Police Officer handles the handover.
2. How do you handle the boy, your colleague's proposal, and the handover to the police?
Read the worked answer
- Separate the boy from your colleague immediately and stay with him in an open, visible place near the counter, not in the godown.
- Recover the bag only. Do not empty his pockets. List the contents on a recovery memo with the time, the shop name and two witness signatures; the school ID card and his name go on the memo.
- Inform the owner's son by phone and note the time of the call and what he said.
- Tell the colleague, once, in front of a witness, that the fine is illegal and that you will report any slap. Silence makes you a co-accused in the assault and in the extortion.
- Call 112/police, log the call time and the arrival time, and hand over the boy, the bag, the memo and a short written statement. Take the officer's name, rank and station and a receipt for the property.
- Nothing is deferred to the morning. A detention that outlives its purpose turns into wrongful confinement, whatever the original offence.
3. How would your answer change if the suspect were an adult woman?
Read the worked answer
The legal basis for detention is the same; the handling changes, because the BNSS search provisions (successors to s.51 CrPC) require that a woman be searched only by another woman, with strict regard to decency.
- No male guard searches her, her bag or her person. Call a female staff member of the shop to be present throughout, and record her name in the memo.
- No closed room and no being alone with her. Detain her in a place visible to others, at a distance, without physical contact.
- Expect an allegation. The female witness is your protection as much as hers; her signature goes on the recovery memo alongside the two witnesses.
- Do not let the colleague 'check her' himself under any pretext - that is the fastest way for the guard and the agency to end up on the wrong side of a criminal case and a PSARA complaint.
- Handover, documentation and escalation are otherwise unchanged.