Notice Writing with Conflicting Instructions
Meera, the cultural secretary, must issue a notice for an inter-house debate. She has three inputs. The principal's handwritten note says: 'Inter-house debate, Friday 18 November, 3:30 pm, AV Room. Topic: "Homework should be abolished". Keep it short.' The AV Room is booked for a physics practical from 3:00 to 4:15 on 18 November. The school bus leaves at 4:15, and the debate needs 45 minutes; the teacher in charge says, 'Finish before the buses.' A student's WhatsApp message says, 'Bring your own topics, it's at 2 pm in the library.' The notice must include date, time, venue, topic, participants, and reporting time, and must not include personal phone numbers.
1. State the final date, time, and venue you would put in the notice. Justify each choice against the constraints, and explain how you would handle the WhatsApp message.
Read the worked answer
Final details: Friday 18 November, 2:00 pm, Library; participants report at 1:45 pm. The AV Room cannot be used at 3:30 because it is booked until 4:15, and a 45-minute debate starting at 3:30 would end at 4:15, exactly when the buses leave. The teacher's instruction is to finish before the buses, so the AV Room slot is impossible. The Library at 2:00 pm allows the debate to end by 2:45, well before 4:15.
The WhatsApp message cannot be treated as authoritative: it comes from a student, invents 'bring your own topics', and conflicts with the principal's set topic. However, its 2 pm Library detail happens to fit the only workable slot. Meera should confirm the Library booking and the 2 pm time with the teacher in charge before printing the notice, then issue it as confirmed information. She should not repeat the 'bring your own topics' line, because the principal specified the topic. The notice should be definite, not provisional, once confirmation is obtained.
2. Draft the notice in 50–60 words. Include all required elements and explain one wording change you made from the student's message.
Read the worked answer
NOTICE Inter-house Debate 18 November, 2:00 pm, Library Topic: 'Homework should be abolished' Participants: all house teams Reporting time: 1:45 pm The debate will end by 2:45 pm so that students can catch the 4:15 bus. Names must reach the cultural secretary by 16 November.
Wording change: The student wrote 'it's at 2 pm in the library', an informal fragment with a contraction. I wrote '18 November, 2:00 pm, Library' as a complete, formal heading. I also replaced 'bring your own topics' with the principal's fixed topic, because a notice must state the authorised topic, not a rumour. The notice omits phone numbers and keeps only the reporting time and the deadline for names, which are necessary for organisation.
3. Identify one piece of information from the inputs that should not appear in the notice, and explain the communication principle behind excluding it.
Read the worked answer
The student's instruction 'Bring your own topics' should not appear, because it contradicts the principal's specified topic and would mislead participants. A notice is an official one-way communication; it should contain confirmed, authorised information, not every message the secretary has received. Including a contradictory student message would create confusion and undermine the authority of the notice.
A second exclusion is any personal phone number. The notice can ask students to contact the cultural secretary by name or through the school office, but publishing a personal number raises privacy concerns and is unnecessary. The principle is fitness for purpose: a notice is short, public, and action-oriented. It should include only what the reader must know to act correctly - date, time, venue, topic, participants, reporting time, and deadline - and leave out rival versions, private contact details, and informal asides.