Home Salon Expansion: EMI Machine Versus a Discount Package
Ritu runs a one-bed home salon in Gurugram. Her monthly fixed costs are rent ₹18,000, electricity ₹4,000 and her own salary ₹25,000. Products and consumables average 8% of service revenue, and her average service ticket is ₹900. She currently completes about 60 services a month and has roughly 200 bookable hours. A company offers her a laser hair-reduction machine on EMI of ₹12,000 a month. At the same time, an influencer suggests launching a '30% off' package to increase footfall. Ritu wants to do both next month and asks you whether the numbers support it. She also plans to post client before-and-after photos, including a client's phone number in one caption, to promote the package.
1. Calculate Ritu's current monthly profit and her break-even point with and without the EMI. Show your working.
Read the worked answer
Current revenue is 60 services × ₹900 = ₹54,000. Variable cost is 8% of revenue = ₹4,320. Contribution is ₹54,000 − ₹4,320 = ₹49,680. Fixed costs without the EMI are ₹18,000 + ₹4,000 + ₹25,000 = ₹47,000. Current profit is ₹49,680 − ₹47,000 = ₹2,680 per month.
The contribution margin ratio is ₹49,680 ÷ ₹54,000 = 0.92, or 92%. Break-even revenue without the EMI is ₹47,000 ÷ 0.92 = ₹51,087, which is about 57 services at ₹900 each. With the EMI, fixed costs become ₹47,000 + ₹12,000 = ₹59,000. Break-even revenue is ₹59,000 ÷ 0.92 = ₹64,130, which is about 72 services. So the machine adds 15 services per month to the break-even point. Ritu's current 60 services cover the old break-even but fall 12 services short of the new one, meaning she would make a loss if demand did not grow.
2. Evaluate whether the 30% discount plus the EMI is viable next month. Use the required service number and compare it with capacity and current demand.
Read the worked answer
At 30% off, the price per service is ₹630. Variable cost is still 8% of revenue = ₹50.40, so contribution per service is ₹579.60. With the EMI, break-even services = ₹59,000 ÷ ₹579.60 = 101.8, so 102 services. Capacity is about 200 hours, and if a service averages one hour, 102 services is physically possible at roughly four services a day over 26 days. But current demand is 60 services, so she would need a 70% increase in one month while also cutting the price. That is not a realistic first-month assumption.
A second calculation shows the risk: if the same 60 clients pay the discounted price, contribution is 60 × ₹579.60 = ₹34,776, against fixed costs of ₹59,000, a loss of ₹24,224. The discount does not create enough extra contribution to cover the EMI. My judgement is not to do both at once. She could trial the machine after building demand, or test a value-added package without the EMI, but launching a deep discount and a new fixed cost together is financially unsafe.
3. Advise Ritu on the digital promotion she has planned and suggest one non-discount way to raise demand.
Read the worked answer
She must not post a client's phone number or any identifying detail. That is personal data, and sharing it without consent can expose her to a privacy complaint and lose client trust. Before-and-after photos also need written consent that explains where the images will appear and for how long. She should avoid misleading edits, avoid claiming medical results, and follow the platform's advertising rules. A simple consent form, a private folder for images and a policy of blurring identifying features would reduce the risk.
A non-discount way to raise demand is to build repeat visits and referrals: a loyalty card after every fifth service, a referral thank-you, a Google Business profile with genuine reviews, and WhatsApp reminders to clients who have opted in. She could also add a small paid add-on to existing services rather than cutting the main price, or approach local offices for a corporate grooming day. These raise revenue per client and protect the 92% contribution margin instead of giving away 30% of every ticket.