A Notice That Would Send Students to the Wrong Room
Ms. Renu is teacher-in-charge of the Literary Club at a senior secondary school. The Principal asks the club secretary, Sameer, to put up a notice about an inter-house debate on the motion 'Social media does more harm than good'. The event is on 18 August at 9:30 a.m. in Room 14 - not the Auditorium, which is being repaired. Students of Classes XI and XII may give their names to their house captains by 12 August. The notice must not exceed 50 words and must be signed 'Secretary, Literary Club'. Sameer submits: 'It is hereby informed to all the students that the Literary Club is going to organise an inter-house debate on the topic "Social media does more harm than good" on 18 August in the Auditorium. Interested students should give their names to the secretary by 12 August. It will be a very good programme. All are invited.' Ms. Renu has to mark it out of 5 and decide whether to ask for a rewrite.
1. Using the three marking criteria for a notice - format, content and expression - identify Sameer's errors and decide how many of the 5 marks you would award. Explain each deduction.
Read the worked answer
- Format (1/2): there is no centred heading 'NOTICE', no date of issue and no boxed layout. A notice is a display text, not a paragraph.
- Content (1/2): the venue is wrong (Auditorium instead of Room 14) and the time is missing. The word limit is also exceeded at roughly 65 words. The venue error is the most serious because it would send students to a closed hall.
- Expression (0.5/1): 'It is hereby informed' is legalistic; 'It will be a very good programme' is advertising, not notice register. 'All are invited' is redundant when Classes XI and XII have already been named.
Total: about 2.5/5. The deduction is not for length alone. A short notice that gives the wrong room is worse than a slightly long notice that gives the right one.
2. Rewrite the notice in 50 words or fewer, preserving every fact the Principal supplied. Then explain why your version is not 'rude' even though it drops phrases such as 'all are invited'.
Read the worked answer
NOTICE Literary Club: Inter-House Debate 18 August, 9:30 a.m., Room 14. Motion: 'Social media does more harm than good.' Students of Classes XI and XII may give names to their house captains by 12 August. Secretary, Literary Club
(38 words)
It is not rude because a notice is a targeted instruction, not a personal invitation. The named audience - Classes XI and XII - is clear, and the required action and deadline are stated. Phrases like 'all are invited' add no information and may even confuse the audience about who is eligible to participate.
3. Sameer asks why the venue error matters so much if the notice is short and neatly written. How would you explain the difference between a factual error and a stylistic weakness in this genre?
Read the worked answer
A stylistic weakness affects how the notice sounds; a factual error affects what readers do. 'It is hereby informed' is clumsy but still understandable. 'Auditorium' when the hall is closed causes a practical failure that no reader can repair. In notices, accuracy is not a cosmetic feature: the text exists to coordinate behaviour on a fixed date at a fixed place. A marker can forgive a slightly informal tone, but a wrong venue or missing time undermines the notice's purpose. That is why content outranks expression when the two conflict.