The juvenile shoplifting suspect and the detention room
At 19:20 you are the only guard at the main door of a supermarket in Panchkula. The cashier is the only other staff member in sight. A sixteen-year-old girl has walked past the billing counter with a sealed backpack, and the EAS pedestal at the exit beeped. She is stopped at the door and, when asked, opens the backpack herself. Inside are two cosmetic items with the store's security tags still attached and no bill; the MRP totals 1,850 rupees. She is crying, says she forgot to pay, and asks to telephone her mother. There is no female staff member on the floor; the only woman on duty is in the accounts office on the first floor, and the store manager has gone to the bank. The store SOP says suspects must be taken to the detention room at the rear and handed to police. You have a two-way radio and a colleague at the rear goods gate.
1. What may you lawfully do in the next fifteen minutes, and what must you not do? Explain the legal basis for each limit.
Read the worked answer
A private security guard has no police powers. The only arrest power available is the citizen's-arrest provision (Section 35 of the BNSS, which replaced Section 43 CrPC), and it is narrow: a non-bailable and cognizable offence committed in the person's presence, with the person then handed to the nearest police officer without delay. It does not authorise investigation, punishment or a confession.
May do: ask her to step aside to a visible area; ask for a bill; ask her name, age and guardian's contact; ask her, in the presence of a witness, whether she will wait for the police; recover the items and list them; call the manager, the female accounts staff and the police.
Must not do: search her person or her bag by hand, especially as a male guard; hold her arm, block her physically, or lock her in a room; threaten her with police or with publicity to extract a payment; take a written 'confession'; or decide the case on the spot. She is a juvenile, so the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act 2015 applies: she cannot be kept in a police lock-up, must be produced before the Juvenile Justice Board, and must not be handcuffed. Note also that first-time theft of property worth under 5,000 rupees, where the property is returned, is dealt with under the community-service route in the BNS rather than custody - so a heavy-handed detention here is both unlawful and disproportionate.
2. The SOP says to use the detention room. Assess that instruction and set out what you would actually do.
Read the worked answer
The instruction is unsafe as written and should be reported as a policy defect afterwards, but in the moment it must be adapted.
The rear detention room is unlit, unwatched, has no female staff, and is out of sight. Detaining a juvenile in a closed room by a male guard creates three problems at once: an allegation of assault or of wrongful confinement that no witness can rebut, a juvenile-protection violation, and a risk of self-harm in an unmonitored space. Even for an adult, confinement is a police function, not a guard's.
What I would do instead: keep her in an open, visible area near the manager's office with the door open and a staff member she can see at all times; call the female accounts staff down to be present for the entire period; offer water and a chair; let her telephone her mother from a phone on speaker or in the presence of the female staff, since a juvenile's guardian must be informed; ask the manager to return; call the police station, give the facts, and ask for a woman officer if one is available. The items are photographed, listed on a property slip and kept sealed in the office safe with a signature. I would not let the matter be 'settled' by a payment at the counter, because that is compounding. Every minute of delay after the police call is recorded.
3. Write the record entries and describe the handover to police so that the file survives scrutiny.
Read the worked answer
The record must be neutral, chronological and quotable.
Incident entry: time the EAS alarmed (19:20); location (exit pedestal); what I observed; that the bag was opened by her, not by me; item names, MRP, tag numbers; her name, stated age and school; her exact words in quotation marks ('I forgot to pay'), not a summary such as 'she admitted theft'; the names of the cashier and the female staff member present as witnesses; the time the guardian was called and the number dialled; the time the manager and the police were informed.
Language discipline: describe, do not label. 'Girl, about 16, blue school bag' is evidence; 'thief' is opinion and will be attacked.
Handover: list the two items on a property slip in duplicate, seal them, and take a signature when they are handed to the investigating officer along with a copy of the register page. Note the officer's name, rank, police station and the FIR or DD entry number. Record whether CCTV of the exit pedestal exists, note the camera ID, and ask the manager to preserve the clip. If the matter ends with a payment or with the guardian's arrival, record that outcome too: an incident file that stops mid-sentence invites the assumption that something was hidden.