Vertex Software: Distributor Discount and Pipeline Risk
Vertex is a B2B workforce-management software vendor selling through regional distributors. Its largest distributor, Halden, has reached 62% of its annual quota with one quarter left. Pipeline coverage is 2.1x, below the 3.0x norm. CRM data shows 45% of open opportunities have had no activity for more than 60 days. Halden is requesting an extra 8% discount on a £420,000 renewal bundle, which would cut Vertex's gross margin from 71% to 66%. Halden's customer satisfaction score is 7.1/10, while direct accounts average 8.4. Vertex's direct sales team has offered to take over the top 20 accounts, but the distributor contract gives Halden exclusive rights to those accounts until renewal. The VP Sales wants to approve the discount to protect the relationship; the CFO wants a pipeline inspection first. Renewal decisions for the top 20 accounts are due in eight weeks.
1. Assess the 8% discount request financially and diagnostically. What should the VP Sales do before deciding?
Read the worked answer
Discount cost: 71% × £420k = £298.2k gross margin; 66% × £420k = £277.2k; concession = £21.0k, or 7.0% of gross margin. A £420k renewal at 66% is still better than losing the account, but only if the account is genuinely at risk. The diagnostic signs point to a pipeline and service problem: 62% of quota with one quarter left, 2.1x coverage versus 3.0x, 45% stale opportunities, and satisfaction 7.1 versus 8.4 direct. Approving an 8% discount without account-level evidence would subsidise a problem and set a precedent. The VP should require a joint pipeline review, verification of competitive threat, and a trade: longer term, upfront payment, case study, volume commitment or marketing funds. Discount only where the expected value of retention exceeds the concession.
2. Design an eight-week recovery plan that respects Halden's exclusive rights while protecting renewals.
Read the worked answer
Eight-week plan: segment the top 20 accounts by renewal value, risk and satisfaction; run a joint Vertex–Halden pipeline scrub, closing or re-qualifying stale opportunities; assign direct overlay support-technical, customer success, executive sponsor-without breaking Halden's contract; create account-level save plans for at-risk renewals; fix service issues driving the 7.1 score; set discount governance so there is no blanket 8%, only case-by-case approval tied to commitments; and track leading indicators weekly. If Halden refuses transparency or service recovery, review the exclusive arrangement after renewal, not before. This respects the contract while protecting revenue.