The Practical Portfolio with Five Days Left
A Class XII vocational student must submit a practical portfolio and face a three-hour practical examination. She has 12 works: four Pattachitra panels, three pencil sketches, two terracotta pieces, one ikat sample and two digital prints. Her portfolio has blurry photographs, no dates or captions, and loose sketchbook sheets in a plastic folder. One Pattachitra closely follows a calendar image; a teacher says it is 'fine because it is traditional'. The exam requires six selected works with evidence of process, source study and original design development. She also must complete one unseen design in three hours and document it. She has five days left, and her best terracotta piece is still drying.
1. Select and sequence six works for the portfolio. Justify your inclusion and omission decisions.
Read the worked answer
Selection should be based on four criteria: originality, range of skills, evidence of process, and quality of finish.
Recommended six:
- One strong Pattachitra panel with visible border, line work and a short note on preparation and pigments.
- A second Pattachitra, preferably a smaller or experimental composition, to show consistency.
- One observational pencil sketch, ideally with two or three preliminary studies on the same sheet.
- One design-development sheet showing motif study, thumbnails, colour trials and a final layout.
- One terracotta piece, if it is dry and sound; otherwise a photograph plus the greenware piece labelled as work in progress.
- The ikat sample, with a short explanation of the tie-resist and colour plan.
Omit the two digital prints unless they are original designs; they add little if they are reproductions. Do not include the copied calendar Pattachitra as an original work. If it is included at all, label it honestly as a master study and place it beside a page showing what she changed. The sequence should move from observation and design development to traditional painting, then craft and three-dimensional work. This tells the examiner a story of process, not a random collection of objects.
2. How should she handle the copied Pattachitra and the teacher's comment?
Read the worked answer
'Traditional' does not mean 'free to copy'. Pattachitra has a shared repertoire of motifs, but the composition, drawing and execution must still be the student's own work unless the piece is explicitly presented as a study copy.
The correct action is to remove the copied work from the position of an original piece. If it is kept, give it a clear label: 'Study after a published calendar image; not submitted as original design'. Add a page showing source analysis-what proportions, border pattern or colour scheme she observed-and then a new composition that applies those lessons. That page turns the copy into evidence of learning rather than concealment.
She should also check the examination's authenticity rules and ask the teacher to confirm them in writing. If the rules forbid copied work entirely, leave it out. The risk of losing marks for misrepresentation is greater than the benefit of one extra painting. This is also a professional habit: artists routinely make master studies, but they do not exhibit them as their own inventions.
3. Plan her five remaining days and the three-hour examination, including documentation. What must be fixed first?
Read the worked answer
Fix the portfolio's evidence before adding anything new.
Five-day plan:
- Day 1: photograph every selected work in daylight against a plain background; reshoot blurry images. Make a list of title, date, size, medium and a two-line process note for each.
- Day 2: bind or mount the loose sketchbook sheets in order. Add captions and a contents page. Insert the source-study page for the copied work.
- Day 3: make the design-development sheet if it is missing: motif study, three thumbnails, colour trials, final layout.
- Day 4: check the terracotta piece. If still damp, do not force-dry it near a heater; photograph it and label it 'greenware, drying'. Select a sound alternative if one exists.
- Day 5: assemble, check sequence, write a short introduction, and rehearse the exam plan.
Three-hour exam: 10 minutes reading and planning; 20 minutes thumbnail studies; 90 minutes main design; 30 minutes adding colour and finishing; 20 minutes documenting the process with notes and a photograph; 10 minutes clean-up and checking. Keep a clock visible.
Documentation must show decisions, not just the final image. A simple 'problem–options–choice' note for the unseen design is more convincing than a decorative border.