Flashing School Zone, Stopped Bus, and a Ringing Phone
At 3:05 p.m. on a Tuesday, you are in the front passenger seat of a dual-brake training car with a 15-year-old learner-permit holder who has held the permit for seven weeks and logged 14 of the required 50 supervised hours. You are on a two-lane road beside an elementary school. The yellow school-zone lights are flashing, and a crossing guard has just stepped into the road. Ahead in your direction, a school bus is stopped with red lights flashing and the stop arm extended. Its front bumper is just past the school driveway, but the bus is still on the roadway, not inside the parking lot. The student's phone rings in the cup holder; the student reaches for it while saying, 'I can go around the bus-it's basically in the parking lot.' A car is approaching from the opposite direction. Traffic is light. The student has not checked the mirror and is still moving at about 25 mph.
1. What should you do in the next three seconds, and why?
Read the worked answer
Immediate action: give a clear, calm command-'Stop. Phone down. Stop before the bus.' Put your hand near or on the instructor brake, and use it if the student does not stop short of the crossing guard and bus. Do not grab the wheel unless the car is drifting into the opposite lane. The reasons are cumulative: the student is at 25 mph in an active school zone; a crossing guard is in the roadway; the bus has red lights and stop arm out; and the student is dividing attention by reaching for a ringing phone. Indiana's hands-free law prohibits holding a phone while driving, and a driver under 18 is barred from using a telecommunications device even hands-free. The oncoming car matters because a panic move around the bus could put the training car into its path. After stopping, have the student secure the phone, take a breath, and scan mirror-left-right before proceeding only when the guard and bus signal allow.
2. Does the bus's position near the driveway change the student's duty to stop? Analyze under Indiana law and explain what the student should have been taught.
Read the worked answer
No. The bus is still on the roadway; its front bumper being near the driveway does not put it inside the parking lot. Indiana requires drivers to stop for a school bus that is stopped to receive or discharge children with red lights flashing and stop arm extended. On a two-lane road, traffic in both directions must stop; the opposite-direction car must also stop. The usual exception is a divided highway with a physical median separating directions, which this is not. The student's 'basically in the parking lot' reasoning is a common rationalization and should be corrected explicitly. Teach the student to identify the stop arm and red lights first, then the bus's location relative to the travel lane, and to stop at least 10 feet before the bus-not to creep forward while deciding. If the bus were fully off the roadway in a private lot, the analysis could differ, but the facts here do not support passing.
3. How should this event be handled in the school's records and follow-up instruction?
Read the worked answer
Document the event in the student's training record the same day: date, time, location, weather, speed, the phone distraction, the bus and guard, your verbal command, whether you used the instructor brake, and the remedial action. Do not falsify or inflate the supervised-driving hours; the time can be logged, but the intervention must be noted. Notify the parent or guardian in writing and schedule a short remedial lesson on school-zone scanning, phone storage, and bus-stop procedures before the next normal lesson. Retain the record for the period the BMV requires and make it available for audit. The follow-up should be instructional, not punitive: have the student narrate the approach to a school zone, put the phone in the glove box before moving, and practice stopping for a simulated bus signal. This creates a defensible record and corrects the specific judgment error.