Declaration Policy: Monthly Declarations, Peak Stock and the July Fire
A wholesale distributor of electronic goods insures stock under a declaration policy with a sum insured of ₹5.00 crore, being the peak level contemplated, and pays a provisional premium. The policy requires the insured to declare the actual value of stock by the 15th of the following month; premium is adjusted at expiry on the average of the declarations, subject to a minimum of 50% of the provisional premium. In June, the actual stock was ₹4.80 crore, but the insured declared ₹3.50 crore. On 28 July, before the July declaration was due, a fire destroyed stock whose actual value at the time was ₹2.00 crore. The insurer applies the declaration policy condition and pays only ₹1.46 crore. The insured argues that the sum insured is ₹5.00 crore, that the June declaration was a mistake, and that the July fire occurred before any July declaration, so the full sum insured should respond.
1. Explain how the declaration policy condition operates and whether the insurer's payment of about ₹1.46 crore is defensible.
Read the worked answer
The declaration policy does not fix ₹5.00 crore as the amount recoverable for every month; it is the maximum or peak sum insured. The insured must declare the actual value at risk, and the premium is adjusted on the declarations. If the declared value is lower than the actual value, the insured is a self-insurer for the difference, and the loss is scaled. For June, the ratio is 3.50 / 4.80 = 0.7292; ₹2.00 crore × 0.7292 = ₹1.458 crore. That arithmetic supports the insurer's figure. The weakness is the date of loss: the fire was on 28 July, before the July declaration was due. The June declaration is evidence of June values, not July values. If the policy says the last declaration governs until a new one is made, the insurer's approach is defensible. If it says the insured must declare the value for each month and the value at the date of loss is used when no declaration has yet been made, the insurer must establish the July actual value; if that was also ₹4.80 crore, the same ratio applies, but the insurer cannot simply assume it. The insurer should check the wording and the July stock records.
2. Advise the insured on the premium adjustment and whether the June under-declaration can be corrected after the loss.
Read the worked answer
A declaration cannot be corrected after a loss to increase the claim. The declaration is a material statement used to fix the premium and the amount at risk; allowing a post-loss correction would let the insured choose the sum insured after knowing the loss and would be contrary to the duty of good faith. The insured can correct an inadvertent error before a loss, and some policies allow a correction within the declaration period if no loss has occurred. After the loss, the insurer is entitled to rely on the June declaration unless the policy has a specific mistake clause. The insured should also check the minimum premium condition: if the average of the declarations is below 50% of the provisional premium, the minimum 50% still applies. The better route is to negotiate on the July actual value if the policy wording supports it, and to ensure future declarations are accurate and timely.