The Letter That Sounds Like a Text
A student drafts a letter to the editor about a cancelled 7:15 a.m. bus route. The task says: 'Write a letter to the editor in 120–150 words. State the problem, give two specific effects, and suggest one practical solution. Use a formal register.' The draft opens: 'Hey Editor, I'm writing to say the 7:15 bus is a real pain. It never comes on time and we are fed up.' It closes: 'Please do something fast. Yours truly, Ravi.' The body has one effect: 'Students are late.' The student has written 96 words. The teacher must decide whether to deduct for register, length, or content first, and how to revise the opening without making the letter sound like a complaint from a stranger. The school's writing checklist gives 2 marks for format, 2 for content, 2 for register, and 1 for length.
1. Identify the three biggest weaknesses in the draft and rank them by mark value. Then rewrite the opening two sentences in a formal register that still sounds like a student.
Read the worked answer
Rank content first: only one effect is given and there is no solution, but the task demands two effects plus one solution, so content is the largest loss. Register second: 'Hey Editor' and 'a real pain' are informal, and 'Please do something fast' weakens the letter's authority; that costs register marks. Length third: 96 words is under 120, but adding the missing content will fix length, so do not pad. Format may also lose a mark if 'Yours truly' is paired with 'Hey'. Rewrite: 'I am writing to draw attention to the cancellation of the 7:15 a.m. bus route, which has disrupted travel for students in our area. Since the route was withdrawn, many of us have missed the first period or paid for shared autos; a restored morning service, even three days a week, would solve most of the problem.' This is formal but not stiff, and it names the writer's stake without 'Hey'.
2. The student asks, 'Can I just add 30 words of adjectives to reach the word limit?' Write a response that explains why this would not earn the length mark and what to add instead.
Read the worked answer
No: length is not a word-count trick. The checklist's length mark assumes the words do the task's work. Adding adjectives ('very serious', 'extremely terrible') inflates the count without adding a second effect or a solution, so the content marks stay low and the register may become overwrought. Add substance instead: a second specific effect, such as 'students who rely on the 7:15 service now reach school after the attendance register closes', and a practical solution, such as 'restore the 7:15 run on weekdays, or add a 7:30 shuttle from the market square'. Then check the count; a 120–150 word letter with two effects and one solution will reach the limit naturally.