Marble Etching in the VIP Suite with 90 Minutes to Arrival
A 180-room five-star hotel is at 94% occupancy. A VIP suite must be ready in 90 minutes. Housekeeping has six attendants on the floor, 22 departures to turn around, and linen returned from the laundry is 18% short. While inspecting the VIP bathroom, the supervisor finds dull etch marks on the marble vanity. A room attendant admits using an acidic bathroom cleaner on the marble because the limestone soap scum was stubborn. In another room, a guest has reported a stained bed runner and wants the room changed immediately. The front office is calling every ten minutes for the VIP suite status. The supervisor must decide the order of work, what to do about the marble, how to allocate the short linen, and what to tell the front office, all without exposing the hotel to a safety or damage claim.
1. Set an order of priority for the next 90 minutes and justify it. Include the VIP suite, the 22 departures, the stained bed runner, and the linen shortage.
Read the worked answer
Prioritise by fixed deadline and guest impact, not by noise. First, secure the VIP suite because the arrival time is fixed and the room is the critical path; the marble treatment and final inspection must start now. Second, respond to the stained bed runner because a guest is waiting and the room change is quick; delaying it turns a linen issue into a complaint. Third, allocate the short linen: protect the VIP suite and occupied rooms first, then departures, because a departure without full linen can still be completed later, while an arriving guest cannot.
The 22 departures are important but flexible within the shift. Six attendants should be split: two on the VIP suite and marble, one on the room change and guest contact, three on departures with linen rationing. The supervisor should inspect the VIP suite personally before releasing it. This order protects the highest-value, least-flexible event, resolves a live guest complaint quickly, and prevents the linen shortage from delaying the only room with a hard deadline.
2. Evaluate the attendant's use of acidic cleaner on marble. What immediate corrective action should the supervisor take, and what should not be done?
Read the worked answer
Marble is calcium carbonate. An acidic cleaner dissolves the surface and leaves etch marks; the damage is chemical, not merely dirt. The attendant chose a strong product to remove soap scum quickly, but the correct product for marble is a neutral pH cleaner with a soft cloth, and the surface should be tested in a hidden area first. The supervisor should stop the use of that chemical immediately, remove the bottle from the floor cart, rinse the vanity with clean water, dry it gently, and call the maintenance or stone specialist. If the specialist cannot arrive before the VIP check-in, use a non-damaging temporary cover and disclose the issue to the front office.
What should not be done: do not scrub harder, do not apply more acid or a harsh abrasive, and do not try to hide the etch with wax or oil, which can stain or become slippery. Record the incident, photograph the damage, and retrain the attendant on chemical labelling and colour coding. The supervisor also needs to check whether the same cleaner was used in other marble bathrooms, because one admitted error often means a repeated practice.
3. What should the supervisor tell the front office about the VIP suite and the linen shortage? Give the wording and the reasoning.
Read the worked answer
Give the front office a clear status, a time, and a contingency, without speculation. For example: 'The VIP suite is being treated for a cosmetic marble issue. It will be ready for inspection at 17:40. If the stone specialist cannot complete the treatment, we will place a temporary protective cover and release the suite, or move the VIP to the alternate suite on the sixth floor. Linen is short by 18%; the suite and occupied rooms are protected, and departures will be completed after those.'
The front office needs certainty to manage the guest and the arrival sequence. Saying 'it will be fine' without a time prevents them from preparing a contingency. Disclosing the cosmetic issue internally also prevents a surprise if the VIP notices the vanity. The supervisor should not promise that the marble is repaired if it is only covered, because that damages credibility. A short written update every 20 minutes is better than repeated phone calls.