Correcting a school concert programme note
During rehearsal for a school showcase, a student's printed programme note contains three claims: (1) 'J.S. Bach's Brandenburg Concerto No. 5, completed around 1721, is a Romantic work because its harpsichord cadenza is intensely expressive'; (2) 'Mozart's Requiem, K. 626, was completed by Beethoven after Mozart's death in 1791'; (3) 'Schubert's Erlkönig, D. 328, is a piano trio from the Classical period.' The concert is limited to 20 minutes and must include one Baroque, one Classical, and one Romantic item. The student has prepared Bach's Brandenburg Concerto No. 5 (first movement), Mozart's Ave verum corpus, K. 618, and Schubert's Erlkönig. The committee wants the note corrected, the programme justified, and the student to explain what actually makes a work 'Romantic' beyond emotional expression.
1. Correct the three factual errors in the programme note.
Read the worked answer
Brandenburg Concerto No. 5 is Baroque, not Romantic. Its harpsichord cadenza is an example of Baroque concerto writing and virtuosic display, not a period label; 'expressive' is not synonymous with 'Romantic.' Mozart's Requiem was left incomplete at his death in 1791 and was completed chiefly by Franz Xaver Süssmayr, not Beethoven. Schubert's Erlkönig is a Lied for solo voice and piano, not a piano trio, and it belongs to the Romantic period (composed 1815), not the Classical period. The corrected note should name the periods accurately and describe the features: Baroque concerto grosso/ritornello and continuo; Classical Viennese style and sacred motet; Romantic Lied and through-composed ballad.
2. Justify a 20-minute programme order using the three prepared items and explain how each represents its period.
Read the worked answer
A 20-minute programme could open with Bach's Brandenburg No. 5 first movement (about 10 minutes), follow with Mozart's Ave verum corpus (about 3–4 minutes), and close with Schubert's Erlkönig (about 4 minutes), totaling roughly 17–18 minutes with pauses. The order is chronological and gives a clear stylistic arc: Baroque ritornello and harpsichord virtuosity; Classical clarity, homophonic choral texture, and restrained expression; Romantic narrative intensity, expanded harmony, and voice-piano partnership. The student should justify each item by period features rather than by audience reaction. If time is tight, the Bach movement can be trimmed only at a cadence, not arbitrarily; the Mozart and Schubert items are short enough to preserve the 20-minute limit.
3. The student argues that any piece with strong emotion is Romantic. Explain why this is historically inadequate, using at least two features of Romantic style and one counterexample from Baroque or Classical repertoire.
Read the worked answer
Emotion is not a period marker: Bach's Passions and Mozart's Don Giovanni are intensely emotional but not Romantic. Romantic style is better defined by changed priorities: individualism and self-expression, expanded chromatic harmony and remote modulations, freer forms and programme music, extremes of tempo and dynamics, and a closer union of music with literature. A Baroque piece may move an audience without sharing those historical features. The student should therefore argue from compositional evidence-harmonic language, form, texture, performing forces-not from felt intensity. That distinction is exactly what the programme note should show.