Baroque violin style and intonation in rehearsal
A violin candidate prepares the first movement of a Handel sonata in F major for the HSC practical exam. In the first rehearsal with the piano accompanist, the candidate plays bars 1–8 at crotchet = 72, with continuous vibrato on every note, heavy détaché bowing, and no ornaments. The pianist's realization is chordal and steady. In bars 17–24, the candidate's intonation rises about 20 cents sharp when shifting to third position on the A string; the pianist notices beating. In a sight-reading exercise, the candidate misreads a dotted quaver–semiquaver figure as a triplet and rushes the bar. The candidate has four weeks and wants a plan that addresses style, intonation, and rhythmic accuracy without sacrificing the performance.
1. Identify three stylistic choices that do not suit a Baroque sonata and explain what to do instead.
Read the worked answer
Three mismatches stand out. First, continuous vibrato on every note is foreign to much Baroque violin playing; vibrato should be selective, narrower, and used as an ornament or for expressive emphasis. Second, heavy détaché bowing gives a legato/romantic weight; a lighter, articulate bow stroke with clear beginnings and less sustain suits the dance-derived phrasing. Third, the absence of ornaments misses cadential trills and appoggiaturas that are stylistically expected, though they should be added tastefully and consistently. Tempo at crotchet=72 may be acceptable, but the character should feel dance-like rather than slow and heavy. The candidate should listen to a period-instrument reference and mark two or three ornamental cadences in the score.
2. Design a two-week practice plan for the third-position intonation and dotted-rhythm sight-reading problems, with specific daily activities.
Read the worked answer
For intonation, spend ten minutes daily on slow third-position scales and arpeggios against a drone, checking the distance between first and fourth fingers and recording the passage. Use a tuner only for spot checks, then rely on beats with the piano. In bars 17–24, practise the shift in isolation, then with the open string as a reference. For rhythm, clap the dotted quaver–semiquaver figure with a metronome on semiquavers, speak 'long–short,' and play it on one note before restoring pitch. In the second week, rehearse bars 17–24 with the pianist at half tempo, then at tempo. Record both weeks and compare. The plan should be daily and short rather than occasional and long.
3. During the rehearsal, how should the violinist and pianist balance and coordinate without the violinist overpowering the keyboard?
Read the worked answer
Balance in a Baroque sonata is a partnership, not a competition. The violinist should agree dynamic levels with the pianist, keep the accompaniment lighter in the right hand, and avoid forcing the tone to dominate. The pianist should voice the bass line clearly but not cover the violin's middle register. Before playing, tune to the piano's A, agree a tempo that allows the ornaments, and mark breathing cues at phrase joins and cadences. At cadential trills, the pianist should wait for the violinist's ornament rather than rushing the harmony. In the exam, the violinist can project by clarity of articulation and phrasing rather than by volume; the pianist can support by reducing texture. A short rehearsal of the cadences alone will prevent most ensemble accidents.