Three Opportunities Near Moga
Gurpreet, 22, lives in a village near Moga. He has ₹3,00,000 of family savings and can borrow up to ₹5,00,000 under a government self-employment scheme. Three things have recently happened near him. (1) A private milk-processing plant has started 18 km away and wants farmers to supply 5,000 litres a day, but its collection centres are few and far apart. (2) A new degree college has opened 4 km away with about 900 students and no canteen; roughly 60% of students come by bus from nearby towns. (3) A neighbouring farmer has bought a silage baler and hires it out at ₹2,200 per acre, but only in October and November. Gurpreet has no formal technical training; he has helped his father farm 6 acres of wheat and fodder and is known locally for getting along with people. He must choose one venture and start within three months.
1. Evaluate the three opportunities against demand evidence, capital needed, competition, seasonality and Gurpreet's own skills.
Read the worked answer
| Criterion | (1) Milk collection centre | (2) College food point | (3) Silage baler |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demand evidence | Strong and stated: plant needs 5,000 L/day; but 'few centres' means the plant's own network may soon cover it | Strong: 900 students, no canteen | Unproven beyond one farmer; demand is local and short |
| Capital | High: chilling tank, testing kit, cans, shed, deposit with plant - could exceed ₹5,00,000 | Moderate: stove, utensils, counter, small kiosk or rented space | Very high: a baler is a large machine; ₹8,00,000 is unlikely to cover it |
| Competition | Plant's own centres plus existing private milk buyers | Weak - no canteen; a few roadside rehris may appear later | One existing baler; a second machine splits a small market |
| Seasonality | Year-round, daily cash | 9–10 months; long vacation gap; 60% bus-commuters leave immediately | Two months a year |
| Skill fit | Needs testing and chilling discipline Gurpreet does not have | Cooking/serving can be hired; his people skills help | Needs machine operation and maintenance knowledge |
Reading the table: the baler fails on capital, seasonality and skills. The milk centre has the best recurring demand but the highest technical and capital demand, and the entry of the plant's own centres is a real threat. The college food point is the best fit for his capital, his skills and the visible gap - with one honest weakness: bus-commuters may not stay to eat.
2. Which venture should Gurpreet choose, what is the single biggest risk, and how should he mitigate it?
Read the worked answer
Choose the college food point - a small tea-and-paratha counter plus a packed-tiffin service.
Reasoning: it uses the smallest share of his ₹3,00,000, needs no licence he cannot obtain in three months, matches his strongest asset (he is good with people), and faces no existing canteen. The milk centre would put his entire borrowing into equipment for a business where the buyer controls the terms and is already building its own network; the baler would tie up all his capital in a machine that earns for two months.
Biggest risk: the 60% who come by bus may buy nothing, because they arrive and leave with the bus. A canteen built for 900 students could end up serving 200.
Mitigation:
- Do not build for 900. Start with a rented counter and a two-item menu for 150 customers a day.
- Add a packed tiffin collected at the gate at a fixed time - this catches bus students who cannot sit and eat.
- Get a written understanding with the college (space, timings, any commission) before spending on the kiosk.
- Keep 30% of capital as a buffer for the vacation months, and test a summer tiffin delivery round to nearby shops and offices.
- Review at 30 days: if daily covers are below 100, cut the menu, not the price.
3. Describe a low-cost validation plan Gurpreet should complete in 10 days before committing money, and the numbers that would make him go ahead or stop.
Read the worked answer
Days 1–2 - Count, don't assume. Stand at the college gate at opening and closing time for two days and count students entering, how many walk to a bus stop, and how many stay past 4 pm. Record numbers, not impressions.
Days 3–5 - Talk to 25 students. Five short questions: what they eat now, where they buy it, what they pay, whether they would buy a ₹40 tiffin, and at what time. Count how many say yes and how many actually name a price they would pay.
Days 6–7 - Check the gatekeepers. Meet the college administration about space, permission, electricity and any commission; check two nearby shopkeepers for rent and footfall. A verbal yes from the college is worth more than 25 student opinions.
Days 8–9 - Test with a stall. Run a two-day trial stall with 60 parathas and 100 cups of tea. Measure what actually sells, what is left over, and the cash left after costs.
Day 10 - Decide with a rule set in advance. Go ahead if: at least 150 students stay on campus at lunch, at least 15 of 25 interviewees say they would pay ₹40, the college confirms space in writing, and the trial stall sells at least 70% of its stock on both days. Stop or change the location if two or more tests fail. The point is to spend a few thousand rupees learning, rather than several lakh learning.