The Two-Income Household and the Micro-Loan
A family of five in a peri-urban ward of Jodhpur reports a monthly income of ₹14,000. The father works as an agricultural labourer for about 120 days a year and as a construction helper for 60 days; the mother rolls bangles at home and is paid ₹2 per piece, averaging 900 pieces a month; the eldest son does app-based delivery on a rented motorcycle. They owe a local moneylender ₹40,000 at 5% per month, taken for a medical emergency. A microfinance institution offers ₹50,000 at 24% annual, with weekly repayment; a bank offers a Kisan Credit Card at 7% but the father is not a landowner. The mother wants to buy a sewing machine for ₹18,000 to take tailoring work; the son wants a smartphone for ₹12,000 to get more orders. A MGNREGA wage payment of 45 days is delayed by three months. The family asks a community facilitator how to use the next ₹20,000.
1. Classify the family's activities into sectors and explain why the classification is not clean.
Read the worked answer
Father: primary (agriculture) and secondary (construction); mother: secondary (bangle rolling as home-based manufacturing) in the informal sector; son: tertiary (delivery services) in the gig economy. The classification is not clean because one household straddles primary, secondary and tertiary activities, and much of the work is informal, so official sector statistics may miss it. The mother's piece-rate bangle work is manufacturing, not a service, even though it is done at home. The facilitator should note that sector labels describe the activity, not the worker's security or income stability.
2. Compare the moneylender, microfinance and bank options, and advise on borrowing for the sewing machine.
Read the worked answer
The moneylender charges 5% per month, about 60% a year, and compounding can double the debt; avoid it. Microfinance at 24% is high but transparent; weekly repayment may strain irregular income. The bank Kisan Credit Card at 7% is cheapest but requires land or a crop plan; the father is not a landowner, so he may need a joint liability group or a self-help group. For the sewing machine, the best route is a bank or self-help group loan at lower cost, with a business plan: ₹2 × 900 = ₹1,800 a month. A ₹18,000 loan at 24% costs about ₹4,320 interest a year, so the machine must raise income by more than that. Do not borrow from the moneylender to repay.
3. What should the facilitator say about the delayed MGNREGA wages and the smartphone?
Read the worked answer
MGNREGA wages are a legal entitlement; the facilitator should help the family check the job card, muster roll and bank account, and complain to the programme officer. For the smartphone, compare need: if it raises delivery orders by at least ₹500 a month, it can pay for itself; otherwise wait. The family should first clear the moneylender with a low-cost loan, not add new consumption debt. The ₹20,000 should be used to reduce the highest-cost debt and to fund the income-earning machine, not split equally between wants.