Seed Rate and Sowing Decision for Rainfed Pearl Millet
A farmer in a 550 mm annual-rainfall district plans 1.0 ha of pearl millet (bajra) on a medium black soil. He has a 90-day hybrid with a 1000-grain weight of 9.0 g and a seed lot with a laboratory germination of 82%. His field records show about 12% of germinated seedlings lost to bird damage, crusting and thinning. He intends to sow on 15 July at 45 cm x 15 cm with a drill calibrated at 3 kg/ha, applying 80 kg N/ha (half basal, half at 30 days) and 40 kg P2O5/ha drilled with the seed. Last season the field gave 1.9 t/ha against a district average of 2.4 t/ha, and he blames 'weak seed'. Rainfall to date is 40% below normal and the fortnight's forecast is 25-35 mm of scattered showers.
1. Calculate the correct seed rate for the intended plant geometry and evaluate the drill calibration of 3 kg/ha.
Read the worked answer
Step 1 - target plant population. Area per plant = 0.45 m x 0.15 m = 0.0675 m2; plants/ha = 10,000 / 0.0675 = 148,148.
Step 2 - allow for germination and field losses. The establishment factor is 0.82 (laboratory germination) x 0.88 (1 - 0.12 field loss) = 0.7216. Seeds to be placed = 148,148 / 0.7216 = 205,306 per ha.
Step 3 - convert to weight. 205,306 x 9.0 g / 1000 = 1,848 g = 1.85 kg/ha. A 10% margin for drill error and bird damage gives about 2.0 kg/ha.
Evaluation: 3 kg/ha is roughly 50% above requirement. That is not a harmless safety margin. Over-population in a 550 mm rainfall district is a well-known cause of yield loss: too many plants compete for a limited water supply, tillering is suppressed, heads are smaller, and the crop runs out of moisture at grain filling. This is a plausible part of the 1.9 vs 2.4 t/ha gap, alongside rainfall and nutrition. It also wastes hybrid seed. The drill should be recalibrated using the actual seed lot (the 1000-grain weight of a treated lot differs from the untreated figure quoted), by running the drill over a measured 1/100 ha on a tarpaulin and weighing the seed collected, and repeating until it delivers 2.0 kg/ha.
2. Given rainfall 40% below normal and a forecast of only 25-35 mm, should he sow on 15 July as planned, with the planned population and basal fertilizer? Give your reasoning and the changes you would make.
Read the worked answer
He should sow, provided the seed zone has enough moisture for germination; the 25-35 mm forecast is enough to wet a medium black soil to sowing depth. Delay is the bigger risk: beyond mid-July a 90-day hybrid runs into terminal moisture stress at flowering and grain filling, and yield falls steeply with each week of delay.
Changes to make:
- Population. Reduce the plant population, by widening rows to 60 cm x 15 cm (111,111 plants/ha) rather than thinning later. This cuts interplant competition for the limited soil moisture, and the seed rate falls to about 111,111 / 0.7216 x 0.009 = 1.39 kg/ha, about 1.5 kg/ha with a margin.
- Basal nitrogen. Cut the basal to 20 kg N/ha (about 43 kg urea) and hold the rest for 30 days, releasing it only if the crop has received follow-up rain. A heavy basal N in a dry season drives vegetative growth that the moisture supply cannot support, and it also raises the salt concentration around the germinating seed.
- Fertilizer placement. 40 kg P2O5/ha as DAP is about 87 kg DAP/ha, which also supplies 15.6 kg N. DAP must not be in direct contact with the seed: place it 5 cm below and 5 cm to the side of the seed row, because ammonia released near a germinating seed reduces emergence, especially in dry soil.
- Moisture conservation. Sow on ridges and furrows, and keep the inter-row cultivated to break the crust and limit evaporation.
3. Critique the planned nitrogen schedule (40 kg N basal + 40 kg N at 30 days) for this crop and soil, and rewrite it with carrier quantities.
Read the worked answer
The split principle is right, but the balance and timing are not suited to a rainfed pearl millet crop in a rainfall-deficit year.
Problems: (a) a 40 kg N basal is half the total, and pearl millet's demand is small until tillering; unused nitrate in a medium black soil at sowing is at risk from leaching and denitrification if heavy rain follows, and from volatilization if urea is left on a dry surface; (b) a single 40 kg dose at 30 days coincides with rapid tillering, but if the rain fails at that point the N sits in dry soil; (c) 80 kg N/ha is generous for a 1.9-2.4 t/ha crop with limited moisture, and excess N encourages lodging and delays maturity.
Revised schedule for 80 kg N/ha (urea 46% N):
- Basal at sowing: 20 kg N/ha = 43 kg urea/ha, banded and covered.
- 25-30 days (tillering, after confirming soil moisture): 30 kg N/ha = 65 kg urea/ha, top-dressed and incorporated or applied with irrigation/rain.
- 45-50 days (boot stage, only if the crop is green and moisture is adequate): 30 kg N/ha = 65 kg urea/ha. Total: 43 + 65 + 65 = 173 kg urea = 80 kg N.
Application rules: never broadcast urea on a dry, hot surface; apply just before expected rain or incorporate lightly; keep urea away from lime and from the seed row; and drop the last split altogether if the rainfall fails, rather than forcing the crop into a terminal drought with a large vegetative frame.