Forty-One Failed DBT Credits at a BC Outlet
At a Business Correspondent (BC) outlet in a tribal hamlet near Kotra, Udaipur, 380 PMJDY accounts have been opened over three years. In January the bank's district office reports that MGNREGA wage payments have failed for 41 accounts for two consecutive months, although the gram panchayat has released the funds. The passbooks of the affected customers largely read 'DBT - not credited'. The reasons gathered by the BC are mixed: 14 customers have Aadhaar numbers never seeded in the account; 9 have a spelling mismatch between Aadhaar and the account name ('Kamla' versus 'Kamala'); 7 hold two accounts and cannot say which one is seeded; 6 accounts have had no customer-induced debit for over two years; and 5 have Aadhaar linked to a joint account where the second holder is the one seeded. Kamla Bai, 34, earns about ₹4,800 a month from MGNREGA and wants ₹60,000 to buy five goats. She has never borrowed. Her balance is ₹0 on most days because she withdraws each credit in full.
1. Group the 41 failures by root cause, give the fix and the owner for each group, and identify the group that is not actually a DBT failure.
Read the worked answer
Four groups are genuine seeding/mapping failures; the fifth is mislabelled.
| Group | Root cause | Fix | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 unseeded | Aadhaar never mapped | Take consent, seed Aadhaar in CBS, then seed the NPCI mapper | BC collects, branch does CBS |
| 9 name mismatch | CBS name differs from Aadhaar | Correct the name in CBS to match Aadhaar (or get Aadhaar updated), re-seed and re-map | Branch |
| 7 two accounts | Duplicate account; the mapper points to one, the customer expects the other | Take the customer's written choice, seed that account, close or transfer the other | Branch |
| 5 joint account | The second holder's Aadhaar is seeded; DBT credits only the primary/first holder's account | Make the intended customer the primary holder, or open a single account and seed it | Branch, with district office for the mapper |
| 6 inoperative | Not a DBT failure - the credit can enter an inoperative account; only the withdrawal is blocked | Reactivate under the inoperative-account procedure (fresh KYC, written request) | Branch |
The sixth group is the one the BC has misfiled: the money may already be sitting in the account and merely cannot be withdrawn. Before any seeding work, the branch should pull the actual credit entries for all 41 accounts - a two-minute CBS query that prevents weeks of pointless re-seeding, and reveals which customers have been told the wrong thing.
Prevention: seed every new account at opening, verify the mapper within a week, and keep a register of seeding status at the outlet.
2. Can the PMJDY overdraft meet Kamla's ₹60,000 requirement? Set out the correct product route and the checks you would apply.
Read the worked answer
The PMJDY overdraft cannot fund this, and offering it would be a mis-sale.
- The OD is ₹10,000, one per household, for customers aged 18-65 who have operated the account satisfactorily for six months with KYC complete. It is an emergency/consumption facility, not a ₹60,000 investment loan.
- Her account has no retention behaviour - every credit is withdrawn in full. That is a positive signal for a small consumption OD (regular MGNREGA credit) but says nothing about servicing ₹60,000.
- Correct route: SHG-bank linkage if she joins or forms an SHG with the required satisfactory operation record; or MUDRA - Shishu up to ₹50,000, Kishor from ₹50,001 to ₹5 lakh, so ₹60,000 falls in Kishor while ₹50,000 (say, four goats) stays in Shishu; or an animal-husbandry loan, which is also covered under the Kisan Credit Card animal-husbandry facility.
- Underwriting checks: purpose and a quotation for the animals; household cash flow (on ₹4,800 a month, an EMI above roughly ₹1,500 is unsafe); expected income from goat rearing; insurance of the animals; and her lack of any repayment track record, which argues for a small, short first loan.
- Do not take her passbook or ATM card as 'security' - that is not a credit decision.
Record on file why the ₹10,000 OD was not offered and why the larger amount was routed to MUDRA/SHG linkage, so the file shows a considered choice rather than a refusal.
3. The BC charges ₹10 per withdrawal and has told Kamla to open a second account at the outlet to 'fix' the DBT problem. Evaluate both practices.
Read the worked answer
Both are violations and should be stopped and reported, not tolerated.
Overcharging. BCs are paid a commission by the bank. Charges to the customer are governed by the bank's agreement and its board-approved tariff, and PMJDY withdrawals at a BC point are not to be charged to the customer. Taking ₹10 per withdrawal from a woman whose monthly credit is ₹4,800 is a breach and a reputational risk; the amounts collected should be refunded and the BC's conduct reviewed.
The second account. Opening another account to 'fix' DBT makes it worse. Only one account per customer can be mapped in the mapper; a duplicate confuses the seeding status and leaves the original account still unseeded. The correct fix is to seed the intended account properly, after correcting the name mismatch.
Conduct. The BC must not handle the customer's Aadhaar OTP, must not get blank or thumb-printed forms signed, and must not keep passbooks or cards.
Action: record the findings, escalate to the branch manager and the BC's controlling officer, reflect them in the BC's performance review, and terminate the agency if it repeats. Give Kamla a written note of her account and seeding status so that she does not have to depend on the BC's verbal assurance - the dependence is what allowed both practices to continue.